asp .net mvc authorization

Question

What is the best way to protect certain areas of your web application in asp .net mvc. I know we can put [Authorization] attribute at each action, but this seems very tedious since you have to put it all over the place. I'm using membership provider and trying the way I used to do in postback model by setting this protection based on the folder. I use web.config <location> section to protect some folders. I tried this in mvc, it seems to be working, but most of tutorial uses the [Authorization] way.

Which one is the better method?

Answer 1

put [Authorisation] at the top of the controller class. that will lock down the entire controllers actions.

Answer 2

I'd highly recommend against putting it in the web.config. Actually, so do Conery, Hanselman, Haack, and Guthrie -- though not highly (p223 of Professional ASP.NET MVC 1.0)

Routes are subject to change, especially in MVC. With the WebForm model, routes are physically represented on the file system so you didn't really have to worry about it. In MVC, routes are "dynamic" for lack of a better term.

You could end up with multiple routes mapping to one controller causing a maintenance pain in the web.config. Worse, you could inadvertently have a route invoke a controller accidentally or forget to update the web.config after adding/modifying routes and leave yourself open.

If, however, you secure your controller instead of the actual route, then you don't need to worry about keeping the web.config in sync with the goings-on of the controllers and changing routes.

Just my 2 cents.