tags:

views:

32

answers:

1
Q: 

Online server for desktop app - implement as web-server or custom socket application?

A bit of a generic question but let's say you have a desktop app that allows a user to connect to a central server and provides functionality like:

  • Login
  • Ability to auto-download profile data on login
  • Download and uploading save files through the app

A web-server (JSP/ASP.NET/PHP/etc) would do lots of work for you especially on the request-serving and threading front, but it seems a bit of a cheat for a desktop app to use HTTP requests like this.

All thoughts welcome. Maybe this should be community wiki?

+1  A: 

If you want to leave things open for other possibilities in the future, go with a web server. That way, if you decide to write a web-based version of your desktop app (or an iPhone/Pre/Android application), you don't have to rewrite your socket server. Almost everything can speak HTTP these days.

David Brown  2009-12-14 23:23:21

related questions

Many threads or as few threads as possible?
Do you know a good cache technology which can be used in .net to share data between a server and many client ?
Response, Result, Reply, which is best?
Server asking the Client for information?
Simple Asynchronous Multi-Threaded HTTP request library for C++
Remoting performance degrades over the time
How to use setspn to enable two java command line processes to authenticate windows process execution identity
j2me service discovery and discoverable same time
Generic Architecture for a Network Server/Client using a State Machine
What are the best ways for maintaining server time
What is the difference between request, response and server?
Server application design methodologies
Multi-client, async sockets in c#, best practices?
Question about WCF Reliable Sessions
Cancelling asynchronous remoting call
How should I stress test / load test a client server application?
Clients to upload data to central server using WCF, how to verify data was uploaded?
(C++) Game Server, (Flash) Client
Scheduled data backup from client to server
How does Telnet server communicate to the client?
db4o client/server appears to only be able to process one query at a time?
What is the best way for a client app to find a server on a local network in C#?
How would you notifiy clients about changed data on the server using .Net 2.0?
Does anyone have database, programming language/framework suggestions for a GUI point of sale system?
Metalanaguage to describe the Model from MVC to generate identical client and server side code