<function> referenced from; symbol(s) not found.

Question

I have a piece of C code that is used from a C++ function. At the top of my C++ file I have the line: #include "prediction.h"

In prediction.h I have this:

#ifndef prediction  
#define prediction  

#include "structs.h"  

typedef struct {  
    double estimation;  
    double variance;  
} response;

response runPrediction(int obs, location* positions, double* observations,
                        int targets, location* targetPositions);

#endif

I also have prediction.c, which has:

#include "prediction.h"  

response runPrediction(int obs, location* positions, double* observations,
                        int targets, location* targetPositions) {  
    // code here  
}

Now, in my C++ file (which as I said includes prediction.h) I call that function, then compile (through Xcode) I get this error:

"runPrediction(int, location*, double*, int, location*)", referenced from:
mainFrame::respondTo(char*, int)in mainFrame.o
ld: symbol(s) not found
collect2: ld returned 1 exit status

prediction.c is marked for compilation for the current target. I don't have any problems with other .cpp files not being compiled. Any thoughts here?

Answer 1

Likely the name of the function is being mangled*. You need to do the following:

extern "C" response runPrediction(int obs, location* positions,
                   double* observations, int targets, location* targetPositions);

Which tells it to treat it as a C function declaration.

_{*C++ mangles function names to give them unique names during the linking phase, for function overloading. C has no function overloading so does no such thing.}

---

Just so you know, you can also make an extern "C" block, if you have multiple things to extern:

extern "C"
{
    response runPrediction(int obs, location* positions,
                   double* observations, int targets, location* targetPositions);

    // other stuff
}

And like Paul suggests, to allow the header to be used in both use __cplusplus to condition it:

#ifdef __cplusplus
    #define EXTERN_C extern "C"
#else
    #define EXTERN_C
#endif

EXTERN_C response runPrediction(int obs, location* positions,
                   double* observations, int targets, location* targetPositions);

Answer 2

Change prediction.h so that it looks like this:

#ifndef prediction  
#define prediction  

#include "structs.h"  

#ifdef __cplusplus
extern "C" {
#endif

typedef struct {  
    double estimation;  
    double variance;  
} response;

response runPrediction(int obs, location* positions, double* observations,
                        int targets, location* targetPositions);

#ifdef __cplusplus
}
#endif

#endif

Answer 3

Is 'prediciton' realy C and not C++? You will have different default compilations based on the file extension, GMan covers this.

If it is ment to be C++ and you change the file name, I would still sugest that runPrediction should be marked extern in the header, it is not defined in the local C++ module defining class mainFrame.