Generating a Protocol Buffers definition

Question

Hi, I have a large set of XML files of a propriatary schema -the XML files define binary communication protocol (message structure).

I'd like to leverage Google's protocol buffers technology.

I am using existing code to load the XML files into an object model (in memory). I'd like to generate a .proto file from that object model.

so basically what I am looking for is code/library (in C#/.NET) that represents the .proto file format as an object model and can save that object model into a .proto file.

I took a look at Jon Skeet's dotnet-protobufs, I think I understand what it does (generate c# code based on .proto files)

However, I didn't figure out if I can use it for my project (it probably has the .proto format object model there, but probably only code that can parse this format and not write it out)

Answer 1

My code can only serialize and deserialize to binary and text. However, I believe Marc Gravell's project has XML capabilities. In fact, I believe he generates C# code based on loading the binary version of a .proto file (which is itself encoded as a protobuf), writing it out as XML, and then applying XSLT to it...

Answer 2

protobuf-net (my version of protocol buffers in .NET) has primitive support for generating proto files, but it wouldn't be hard to fill in the blanks. I concentrated on the core engine first, then the generation of C# from proto. Writing an xslt to generate a proto from the object model wouldn't be much different. It would take a few days though... (I have limited time at the moment).

If this would be useful, please let me know.

For info, the protobuf-net engine is compatible with most XmlSerializer classes (and DataContractSerializer, and recently BinaryFormatter) - so if your code currently works as xml, we can probably get it working in protobuf-net. No guarantees, of course...