In PHP settings, should memory_limit > upload_max_filesize?

Question

I'm trying to allow users to upload large files (64MB) and am planning to change:

    upload_max_filesize to 64MB

However, should I also change

  memory_limit to 64MB or larger?

Is memory_limit connected to max_filesize?

Answer 1

Yes; memory_limit needs to be bigger than upload_max_filesize.

You'll also need to increase post_max_size ... as files are uploaded via a POST request.

Answer 2

I typically use upload_max_filesize<post_max_size<memory_limit as a rule of thumb, when configuring PHP.

Answer 3

post_max_size must be bigger than upload_max_filesize. If a form contains more file uploads then the post_max_size must be greater than the sum of them.

The memory_limit does not have any significant role in file uploads, as uploaded files are stored in the /tmp (Linux) directory, not in memory. If you want to submit large amount of data with form fields (not file uploads) then you need a big memory_limit otherwise not.

Answer 4

No, it's not necessary.

PHP has different POST readers and handlers depending on the content type of the request. In case of "multipart/form-data" (what is used for sending files), rfc1867_post_handler acts as a mixed reader/handler. It populates both $_POST and $_FILES. What goes into $_POST counts towards the memory limit, what goes into $_FILES also counts.

However, $_FILES has just meta-data about the files, not the files themselves. Those are just written into the disk and hence don't count towards the memory limit.