tags:

views:

33

answers:

1

Hi
I have 2 classes which represent a matrix:
1. RegularMatrix - O(n^2) representation
2. SparseMatrix - a matrix that is represented as linked list (without zeros).

lets say i have:

RegularMatrix a;
SparseMatrix b;

i want to be able to do:

a+b;

and also:

b+a;

so i'm overloading the + operator. My question is, since I want the addition to be commutative (a+b = b+a), do i need to implement 2 overloadings, one for each case?

RegularMatrix operator+(const RegualarMatrix &, const SparseMatrix &);
RegularMatrix operator+(const SparseMatrix & ,const RegualarMatrix &);

or is there a general form which the compiler decides by itself?

Thank you

+2  A: 

Yes you need both versions. But you can forward the one to the other, if the operation really is commutative

RegularMatrix operator+(const SparseMatrix &a, const RegualarMatrix &b) {
    return b + a;
}
Johannes Schaub - litb
Yeah. Sure. Sneak in a few seconds ahead of me. Like you really need the points...
dmckee
Thank you.. And one more thing i'm curious about, is it considered better programming to return a reference of RegularMatrix than to return the object by value?
rob
@dmckee: To be fair, it was more than a minute. `:)`
sbi
@sbi: Granted. But I got the notification just as I as reaching for my mouse to post mine...
dmckee
@dmckee: I hear you. The same just happened to me right after I wrote that comment to you...
sbi