views:

227

answers:

2

We currently generate reports in MS Excel format. Our client just called to ask if we could generate those reports in OpenOffice format instead.

Their reason is that their entire office is being purged of Microsoft Office, as their license has expired, and they are no longer willing to renew their license. As a consequence, they want our application to NOT generate Excel files as well.

So, does opening Excel files require the viewer to have a Microsoft Office license, even if the file is to be opened by OpenOffice Spreadsheet? Or is it prohibited by the license to do so? Can anybody provide links to any legal text of some sort?

As far as I know, there is no such restriction. But I'd like to make sure and be confident about it when I respond to our client.

Thanks!

+8  A: 

The Excel files belong to your clients (or you maybe). They can open them with whatever they want - a hex viewer, an image viewer, or even Open Office.

I'd guess Open Office probably has a better chance of letting them look at the data in a manner they're accustomed to. However, if OpenOffice has problems with the files, they can always get a free viewer app from Microsoft (if all they want to do is look at the files - not modify them).

Microsoft doesn't make getting their viewers as easy as they should (in my opinion), particularly if you want to view files that are in the newer Office 2007 formats. Here's a KB article on how:

Michael Burr
Binary Worrier
And +1 to the other guy for not giving me concussion :-) MS should make getting those easier since it could stop people moving to OOo. But maybe if few people know about them, they'll buy MSOffice. Bit of a tightrope for MS, I'd say.
paxdiablo
I'd up this answer, if I had the reputation points.. =p Thanks, too!
Nikki Erwin Ramirez
@Pax How would a "viewer" stop me from using OOo? I need to _work_ with the data, not only view them.
Daniel Daranas
+10  A: 

There is no such restriction. The specifications are placed under the Microsoft Open Specification Promise, guaranteeing there also won't ever be such a restriction.

Joey
"MS's Open Specification promise": haha, I lauged so much I fell off my chair. Now I'm sitting in the sick room at work waiting for an ambulance. I think I may have concussion :-) +1 for making me laugh.
paxdiablo
Ah well, let a young man have his illusions :D Nevertheless, it's as good as you can get, at least with the binary formats. Not going into a flame war on OOXML and being an international standard now :)
Joey
Thanks! Nice to know this! :D(I'm off to look for online text of that "promise".. :D )
Nikki Erwin Ramirez