views:

724

answers:

4

Anybody have any experience with 3rd Party WinForm .NET grid controls?

Before I spend the afternoon downloading and trying out several of the grids and/or control packs, anybody have opinions on vendors? functionality? etc.

Some of the ones I'll be looking at are:

  • XCeed Grid
  • Telerik Grid - Part of RadControls for WinForms
  • Infragistics NetAdvantage WinClient for WinForms

Any reviews online? Comparison charts?

+3  A: 

This will undoubtedly get closed as subjective, but I'll go ahead and throw my full, unqualified support behind the DevExpress suite of controls, specifically the XtraGrid. I have never worked with another control that had as much speed, customizability, and both reliable and robust designer support.

I'm using Telerik in my current job, and while the version I have now is lightyears better than the version I started with, I still don't think it holds a candle to DevExpress's offering.

Adam Robinson
Any specifics to what makes the DevExpress Grid more robust? Any killer features that it has and Telerik doesn't?
tyndall
DevExpress is better on winforms and Telerik is better on ASP.Net suite controls. I have used both the control suites and can surely say that from my experience.
Vikram
+1  A: 

Component one's C1.FlexGrid is quite handy. If you're not looking to spend any money, the built in grid in 3.5 is quite useful.

jblaske
I'm looking for something that makes it ridiculously simple to do nested controls, validation, and grouping/sorting. Extra features are nice.
tyndall
+1  A: 

I use Infragistics. It's very powerful, but can be difficult to set up for simple tasks. I haven't experienced any major problems or bugs. Their forums are pretty good for support, and they release updates quarterly (with serious bug fixes available more frequently).

Jon B
Agreed with all points here - the documentation is not great, the source code sometimes hard to read and is full of developer comments about a bugfix and a date, but you can do pretty much anything iwth the infragistics grid. Very powerful.
jean
+1  A: 

Our experience with ComponentOne's C1 grid is just terrible. It blew up on our face when customers in the US government had FIPS policy in place and their customer support merely informs us - "yes, you are right, we are not FIPS compliant". Thank you very much and apart from that, the so-called virtual mode is just no good for large data.

anon
what is FIPS? never heard of that
tyndall
Federal Information Processing Standards ! There is a policy setting which prevents .NET from allowing the instantiation of anything that uses "banned" hashing algorithms like MD5 etc ! And all the US Government installations set up this system policy... ComponentOne confirms the problem, have no solution and do not seem to think that US Government policies matter to their customer's business.
anon