Improving performance reflection , what alternatives should I consider

Question

Hi,

I need to dynamically set values on a bunch or properties on an object , call it a transmission object. There will be a fair number of these transmission objects that will be created and have its properties set in a short space of time.I want to avoid the use of reflection, are there alternativ? If so are there sample implementations I could look at?

Thanks

Answer 1

Have you established with certainty that using reflection is too slow? Although reflection in .NET is not as fast as static code, it is still extremely fast. You should write the code in the easiest way possible - even if that uses reflection - and only come back to optimize if you notice performance problems and isolate them to your use of reflection. Most of the time, you won't have any problems. Reflection is used in all kinds of performance-sensitive code, such as ASP.NET MVC.

Answer 2

You can use lightweight code generation here's some articles:

• http://blogs.msdn.com/joelpob/archive/2004/04/01/105862.aspx
• http://wesnerm.blogs.com/net_undocumented/2005/06/lightweight_cod.html
• Dyanamic Method

Answer 3

Reflection got a bad rep from Java where it is (or at least used to be) very slow. This is not the case in .net so I don't understand your objection on using it. Also I agree with Rex, you can't say something has poor performance without actually measuring.

Answer 4

Reflection can be blazingly fast if you do it right (not as fast as static code, of course).

Finding a property-setter is slow. Invoking a delegate is fast.

You need to get and cache Delegate objects for each property-setter on each type of DTO. That's the slow part, but it's a one-time hit. Then you can Invoke each of the cached delegates for the property-setters of a given DTO type, passing in the DTO object and the new property value, but this part will be very fast.

Answer 5

Use Delegate.CreateDelegate to turn a MethodInfo into a strongly-typed delegate. This can improve performance massively. I have a blog post about this with sample code. Note that this is only going to help if you need to set the same properties multiple times - basically it means that a lot of the type checking is done once when you create the delegate, rather than on every invocation.

Marc Gravell has a HyperPropertyDescriptor project which achieves even better performance, but introduces an extra dependency.

Answer 6

In .NET 4.0 (beta), you can do this with the updated expression trees, using Expression.Block and Expression.Assign - then compile that to a typed delegate; job done.

In .NET 2.0 and above (as Jon mentioned) HyperDescriptor is a reasonable option - it works as a custom PropertyDescriptor implementation, so you just do code like:

// store this collection for optimum performance
PropertyDescriptorCollection props = TypeDescriptor.GetProperties(
    typeof(SomeType));
props["Name"].SetValue(obj, newName);
props["DateOfBirth"].SetValue(obj, newDoB);

This still has a little boxing, but that isn't actually a bottleneck.