Easier way to start debugging a windows service in C#

Question

Is there a way to easier start stepping through code except to start the service through the Windows Service Controll Management and then attach the debugger to the thread? It's kind of cumbersome and I'm wondering if there is not a more straight-forward approach.

Answer 1

You can also start the service through the command prompt (sc.exe).

Personally, I'd run the code as a stand-alone program in the debugging phase, and when most bugs are ironed out, change to running as service.

Answer 2

What I used to do was to have a command line switch which would start the program either as a service or as a regular application. Then, in my IDE I would set the switch so that I could step through my code.

With some languages you can actually detect if it's running in an IDE, and perform this switch automatically.

What language are you using?

Answer 3

What I usually do is encapsulate the logic of the service in a separate class and start that from a 'runner' class. This runner class can be the actual service or just a console application. So your solution has (atleast) 3 projects:

/ConsoleRunner
   /....
/ServiceRunner
   /....
/ApplicationLogic
   /....

Answer 4

I think it depends on what OS you are using, Vista is much harder to attach to Services, because of the separation between sessions.

The two options I've used in the past are:

• Use GFlags (in the Debugging Tools for Windows) to setup a permanent debugger for a process. This exists in the "Image File Execution Options" registry key and is incredibly useful. I think you'll need to tweak the Service settings to enable "Interact with Desktop". I use this for all types of debugging, not just services.
• The other option, is to separate the code a bit, so that the service part is interchangable with a normal app startup. That way, you can use a simple command line flag, and launch as a process (rather than a Service), which makes it much easier to debug.

Hope this helps.

Answer 5

For routine small-stuff programming I've done a very simple trick to easily debug my service:

On start of the service, I check for a command line parameter "/debug". If the service is called with this parameter, I don't do the usual service startup, but instead start all the listeners and just display a messagebox "Debug in progress, press ok to end".

So if my service is started the usual way, it will start as service, if it is started with the command line parameter /debug it will act like a normal program.

In VS I'll just add /debug as debugging parameter and start the service program directly.

This way I can easily debug for most small kind problems. Of course, some stuff still will need to be debugged as service, but for 99% this is good enough.

Answer 6

When I write a service I put all the service logic in a dll project and create two "hosts" that call into this dll, one is a Windows service and the other is a command line application.

I use the command line application for debugging and attach the debugger to the real service only for bugs I can't reproduce in the command line application.

I you use this approach just remember that you have to test all the code while running in a real service, while the command line tool is a nice debugging aid it's a different environment and it doesn't behave exactly like a real service.

Answer 7

When developing and debugging a Windows service I typically run it as a console application by adding a /console startup parameter and checking this. Makes life much easier.

static void Main(string[] args) {
    if (Console.In != StreamReader.Null) {
        if (args.Length > 0 && args[0] == "/console") {
            // Start your service work.
        }
    }
}

Answer 8

How about Debugger.Break() in the first line?

Answer 9

If I want to quickly debug the service, I just drop in a Debugger.Break() in there. When that line is reached, it will drop me back to VS. Don't forget to remove that line when you are done.

UPDATE: As an alternative to #if DEBUG pragmas, you can also use Conditional("DEBUG_SERVICE") attribute.

[Conditional("DEBUG_SERVICE")]
private static void DebugMode()
{
    Debugger.Break();
}

On your OnStart, just call this method:

public override void OnStart()
{
     DebugMode();
     /* ... do the rest */
}

There, the code will only be enabled during Debug builds. While your at it, it might be useful to create a separate Build Configuration for service debugging.

Answer 10

UPDATE

This approach is by far the easiest:

http://www.codeproject.com/KB/dotnet/DebugWinServices.aspx

I leave my original answer below for posterity.

---

My services tend to have a class that encapsulates a Timer as I want the service to check at regular intervals whether there is any work for it to do.

We new up the class and call StartEventLoop() during the service start-up. (This class could easily be used from a console app too.)

The nice side-effect of this design is that the arguments with which you set up the Timer can be used to have a delay before the service actually starts working, so that you have time to attach a debugger manually.

p.s. How to attach the debugger manually to a running process...?

using System;
using System.Threading;
using System.Configuration;    

public class ServiceEventHandler
{
    Timer _timer;
    public ServiceEventHandler()
    {
        // get configuration etc.
        _timer = new Timer(
            new TimerCallback(EventTimerCallback)
            , null
            , Timeout.Infinite
            , Timeout.Infinite);
    }

    private void EventTimerCallback(object state)
    {
        // do something
    }

    public void StartEventLoop()
    {
        // wait a minute, then run every 30 minutes
        _timer.Change(TimeSpan.Parse("00:01:00"), TimeSpan.Parse("00:30:00");
    }
}

Also I used to do the following (already mentioned in previous answers but with the conditional compiler [#if] flags to help avoid it firing in a Release build).

I stopped doing it this way because sometimes we'd forget to build in Release and have a debugger break in an app running on a client demo (embarrasing!).

#if DEBUG
if (!System.Diagnostics.Debugger.IsAttached)
{
    System.Diagnostics.Debugger.Break();
}
#endif

Answer 11

What you need is thinking of Simplifying Windows Services

Answer 12

I also think having a separate "version" for normal execution and as a service is the way to go, but is it really required to dedicate a separate command line switch for that purpose?

Couldn't you just do:

public static int Main(string[] args)
{
  if (!Environment.UserInteractive)
  {
    // Startup as service.
  }
  else
  {
    // Startup as application
  }
}

That would have the "benefit", that you can just start your app via doubleclick (OK, if you really need that) and that you can just hit "F5" in Visual Studio (without the need to modify the project settings to include that "/console" Option).

Technically, the "Environment.UserInteractive" checks if the WSF_VISIBLE Flag is set for the current window station, but is there any other reason where it would return false, apart from being run as a (non-interactive) service?

Answer 13

To debug Windows Services I combine GFlags and a .reg file created by regedit.

1. Run GFlags, specifying the exe-name and vsjitdebugger
2. Run regedit and go to the location where GFlags sets his options
3. Choose "Export Key" from the file-menu
4. Save that file somewhere with the .reg extension
5. Anytime you want to debug the service: doubleclick on the .reg file
6. If you want to stop debugging, doubleclick on the second .reg file

Or save the following snippets and replace servicename.exe with the desired executable name.

---

debugon.reg:

Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00

[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows NT\CurrentVersion\Image File Execution Options\servicename.exe]
"GlobalFlag"="0x00000000"
"Debugger"="vsjitdebugger.exe"

---

debugoff.reg:

Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00

[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows NT\CurrentVersion\Image File Execution Options\servicename.exe]
"GlobalFlag"="0x00000000"

Answer 14

---

static void Main()
{
#if DEBUG
                // Run as interactive exe in debug mode to allow easy
                // debugging.

                var service = new MyService();
                service.OnStart(null);

                // Sleep the main thread indefinitely while the service code
                // runs in .OnStart

                Thread.Sleep(Timeout.Infinite);
#else
                // Run normally as service in release mode.

                ServiceBase[] ServicesToRun;
                ServicesToRun = new ServiceBase[]{ new MyService() };
                ServiceBase.Run(ServicesToRun);
#endif
}

Answer 15

#if DEBUG
    System.Diagnostics.Debugger.Break();
#endif

Answer 16

Thanks everyone! It worked Great!

Answer 17

I use a variation on JOP's answer. Using command line parameters you can set the debugging mode in the IDE with project properties or through the Windows service manager.

protected override void OnStart(string[] args)
{
  if (args.Contains<string>("DEBUG_SERVICE"))
  {
    Debugger.Break();
  }
  ...
}

Answer 18

Use the HuwmanCode Framework available at huwmancode.codeplex.com, this framework enables seamless debug support for .Net Windows services. It also enables the development of Windows Services without the use of Service Projects.