views:

379

answers:

2

Even looking closely over documentation on Clojure, I do not see any direct confirmation as to whether or not Clojure supports operator overloading.

If it does, could someone provide me with a quick snipplet of how to overload, let's say, the "+" operator to delegate to some predefined method that we can call myPlus.

I am very new to Clojure, so someone's help here would be greatly appreciated.

+3  A: 

Take a look at this: http://clojure.org/multimethods

Certain functions, like + are core and cannot be redefined.

You could make a new function and call it ".+" or "!+" for example, which is similar in terms of readability.

Using the information in the multimethods URL included above, you can build a function that tells your .+ which implementation to use.

z5h
You didn't answer his question one way or the other.
chollida
I've added more info.
z5h
The updates really help make this a better answer!
chollida
+13  A: 

Clojure's (as any Lisp's) operators are plain functions; you can define a "operator" like a function:

(defn ** [x y] (Math/pow x y))

The "+" operator (and some other math-operators) is a special case in Clojure, since it is inlined (for the binary case, at least). You can to a certain extent avoid this by not referring to clojure.core (or excluding clojure.core/+) in your namespace, but this can be very hairy.

To create a namespace where + is redefined:

(ns my-ns
  (:refer-clojure :exclude [+]))

(defn + [x y] (println x y))

(+ "look" "ma")

One good strategy would probably to make your + a multimethod and call core's +-function for the numeric cases.

pmf
So, if I were to exclude clojure.core/+, I could do the following (defn + [x y] (myPlus x y)) correct? If so, that is exactly what I want to do. How do I exclude clojure.core/+ from my namespace?
Ryan Delucchi
I've added this to my answer.
pmf
Bingo, exactly what I am looking for! Thanks.
Ryan Delucchi
Actually, after trying this: it doesn't seem to work. I try it and get the following error: java.lang.Exception: Name conflict, can't def + because namespace: my-ns refers to:#'clojure.core/+ (NO_SOURCE_FILE:5)
Ryan Delucchi
My mistake! It works :-) ignore my last comment
Ryan Delucchi
Please enable public editing so I can fix my vote on your answer (and give you a well-deserved +1)
Ryan Delucchi
I don't actually know how to do this.
pmf
Make some arbitrary changes to your answer, and I should be able to fix my voting mistake.
Ryan Delucchi