rsacryptoserviceprovider using x509 certificates c#

Question

i am using a certificate generated by makecert which has both private and public key. The java side uses this public key to encrypt the data and .net decrypts it back.

I am trying to decrypt Java's encrypted 64 bit encoded string and getting bad data.

To see if all is good on.Net end, I frist tried to encrypt with the public key and then decrypt with private using the same certificate. My code looks like this.

        X509Certificate2 cert = GetCert(key, StoreName.My, StoreLocation.LocalMachine);
        RSACryptoServiceProvider provider =  (RSACryptoServiceProvider)cert.PrivateKey;

        RSACryptoServiceProvider publicprovider = (RSACryptoServiceProvider)cert.PublicKey.Key;

        if (cert.HasPrivateKey)
            MessageBox.Show("Got private key");

        byte[] encrypted = publicprovider.Encrypt(Encoding.UTF8.GetBytes(text), false);
        byte[] decryptedBytes = provider.Decrypt(encrypted, false);

Even here I am getting the error. Am i Missing something?

The certificate looks valid with both public and private key.

Answer 1

The following code works fine for me:

        RSACryptoServiceProvider privateKey = new RSACryptoServiceProvider();
        privateKey.FromXmlString("<RSAKeyValue><Modulus>wL8s+C8SnnlaaqR+VsyijmxOJOARNa4o7ZNsqfy3+9J9Ol2JNSjjMfQWoUnFtClzJBlZhU5KtuazQe8ZKXTX9YvKoJdRhlsonZkC04qiTMdO/FZIH00GrCRxeQ7XDnQnvPB9Bdsvs//7zrY3f7eLIkpIyK9cQHU+5jjJd5IT0eE=</Modulus><Exponent>AQAB</Exponent><P>83xxN7jvpg5z16pxz2tIQIdqd/EfmikR9Q2TjG2tosWkUSvtyx0xHZ9EqdTUbSGZZ+jgrabzkafYc7Mplylwew==</P><Q>yqcnYSZEXHwJvRWi2V09PNEENTozQZywcFptUUGar9TciaQvoNv3lpnfzUKNBRdhzq4lImxkamajZlTWE5buUw==</Q><DP>37HqilkbwyHwB6mOGhPkM3S1ujAK6qTk3JB2iEOTjMGrru9+7maJYz+Z47Wm3ARMXgyzrpZ9m8nqsJFfmoL11Q==</DP><DQ>v285tv8kMs2FkZYfuP/oOkwkkneBNejjj68Md2bmzlThZDCyQV2pvB1tmgPVHUsiPNCrCaKlFRISJzfa5rR8Ow==</DQ><InverseQ>fgJE2TRe/SS+YqW0/I+FtHrdfbbao0/R3pHD4r4oceZQUemlBgZ7DxOAetebHKthlOdjGkmfWYB8EU4XoWggqw==</InverseQ><D>FMLCwjy3wbAKiCANp6XFAJgz1o7365NFv0k41BpvasViTa4TgFFWH2ROJ7M9g0lPqJy+YrhrHcY9mqV5TVjTheQp0JeckrgO2B39XngPMAMMdne3rWGpf0Pfbj3FLfchMk6XYDXSZzCS2CmSeRA4aBMb+4R3YurixyJLrnGRMH0=</D></RSAKeyValue>");
        RSACryptoServiceProvider publicKey = new RSACryptoServiceProvider();
        publicKey.FromXmlString("<RSAKeyValue><Modulus>wL8s+C8SnnlaaqR+VsyijmxOJOARNa4o7ZNsqfy3+9J9Ol2JNSjjMfQWoUnFtClzJBlZhU5KtuazQe8ZKXTX9YvKoJdRhlsonZkC04qiTMdO/FZIH00GrCRxeQ7XDnQnvPB9Bdsvs//7zrY3f7eLIkpIyK9cQHU+5jjJd5IT0eE=</Modulus><Exponent>AQAB</Exponent></RSAKeyValue>");

        {
            string text = "foo";
            byte[] encrypted = publicKey.Encrypt(Encoding.UTF8.GetBytes(text), false);
            byte[] decryptedBytes = privateKey.Decrypt(encrypted, false);
        }

Can you double-check that the exported private key is from cert.PrivateKey and the public key is from cert.PublicKey.Key?

Answer 2

Here's the private key and public key

Private

<RSAKeyValue><Modulus>wL8s+C8SnnlaaqR+VsyijmxOJOARNa4o7ZNsqfy3+9J9Ol2JNSjjMfQWoUnFtClzJBlZhU5KtuazQe8ZKXTX9YvKoJdRhlsonZkC04qiTMdO/FZIH00GrCRxeQ7XDnQnvPB9Bdsvs//7zrY3f7eLIkpIyK9cQHU+5jjJd5IT0eE=</Modulus><Exponent>AQAB</Exponent><P>83xxN7jvpg5z16pxz2tIQIdqd/EfmikR9Q2TjG2tosWkUSvtyx0xHZ9EqdTUbSGZZ+jgrabzkafYc7Mplylwew==</P><Q>yqcnYSZEXHwJvRWi2V09PNEENTozQZywcFptUUGar9TciaQvoNv3lpnfzUKNBRdhzq4lImxkamajZlTWE5buUw==</Q><DP>37HqilkbwyHwB6mOGhPkM3S1ujAK6qTk3JB2iEOTjMGrru9+7maJYz+Z47Wm3ARMXgyzrpZ9m8nqsJFfmoL11Q==</DP><DQ>v285tv8kMs2FkZYfuP/oOkwkkneBNejjj68Md2bmzlThZDCyQV2pvB1tmgPVHUsiPNCrCaKlFRISJzfa5rR8Ow==</DQ><InverseQ>fgJE2TRe/SS+YqW0/I+FtHrdfbbao0/R3pHD4r4oceZQUemlBgZ7DxOAetebHKthlOdjGkmfWYB8EU4XoWggqw==</InverseQ><D>FMLCwjy3wbAKiCANp6XFAJgz1o7365NFv0k41BpvasViTa4TgFFWH2ROJ7M9g0lPqJy+YrhrHcY9mqV5TVjTheQp0JeckrgO2B39XngPMAMMdne3rWGpf0Pfbj3FLfchMk6XYDXSZzCS2CmSeRA4aBMb+4R3YurixyJLrnGRMH0=</D></RSAKeyValue>

Public

<RSAKeyValue><Modulus>wL8s+C8SnnlaaqR+VsyijmxOJOARNa4o7ZNsqfy3+9J9Ol2JNSjjMfQWoUnFtClzJBlZhU5KtuazQe8ZKXTX9YvKoJdRhlsonZkC04qiTMdO/FZIH00GrCRxeQ7XDnQnvPB9Bdsvs//7zrY3f7eLIkpIyK9cQHU+5jjJd5IT0eE=</Modulus><Exponent>AQAB</Exponent></RSAKeyValue>

which seems to match

Answer 3

I finally found the problem. I wasn't putting the key to makecert to define it as RSA Crypto key.

Answer 4

I had the same problem with a self-signed cert, the issue was that I was generating the cert with the switch -sky signature instead of -sky exchange (you use signature for signing and exchange for encryption/decryption)

Here is my full command to makecert that works:

makecert -r -pe -a sha1 -n "CN=MyName" -ss my -sr CurrentUser -sky exchange