views:

375

answers:

7

I am wondering if this is possible in JavaScript, I want to have an Object which could contain dynamic properties.

Give an example:

function MyObject()
{
}

var myobj = new MyObject();
myobj.property1 = "something";

alert(myobj.property1); // something
alert(myobj.property2); // this should never report error, instead the property should be evaluated to null, as it has never been set.

Is there any way to intercept property calls in JavaScript so I can proactively set a no-value property as null?

Thanks.

+1  A: 

Nope. JavaScript is not Smalltalk.

Jonathan Feinberg
Then, i guess that I should do something like this: MyObject.prototype.getProperty = function(name){ if (this.hasOwnProperty(name)) return this[name]; else return null;}Then, I will use myobj.getProperty(propertyName) when I need to access it. Looks like this is the best option.
Nominee
A: 

No unless you are manipulating an object controlled by an NPAPI plugin in which case you could implement the intended behavior.

In other words, through an NPAPI plugin, you could implement the behavior you are looking for.

jldupont
+1  A: 

This is about as close as you can get to achieving your goal.

Code:

var obj = {};
alert("prop: " + obj.prop);
obj.prop = "something";
alert("prop: " + obj.prop);
delete obj.prop;
alert("prop: " + obj.prop);

Behavior:

Alert: "prop: undefined"
Alert: "prop: something"
Alert: "prop: undefined"
geowa4
+1  A: 

Check out javascript prototypes. I think that will give you at least some of what you are looking for. Just google up "javascript prototype".

Jim Leonardo
A: 

In your example the second alert will not generate an error. It will just alert undefined. Accessing properties of properties will generate an error:

myobj.property2.property3
Jason Harwig
+1  A: 

There is no way to intercept direct property accesses in JavaScript. When a property is retrieved that hasn't been set than the result will be undefined. Although null and undefined are usually considered to be the same thing they are in fact different entities.

In JavaScript undefined means no value and null means a value of null. In some cases you can mix undefined and null. For example, when using the == operator they are equivalent ((null == undefined) === true). Using the non-coercing operator, ===, they are different ((null === undefined) === false).

You can use this to your advantage. While most people will claim that you should use the non-coercing equality operator (===) it's mostly safe to put null and undefined in the same bucket, in less of course you actually care about the difference between the two. Where it gets tricky is that undefined is a property of the global object and can therefore be assigned a new value.

If someone were to say undefined = 'donkey' then null == undefined would start to return false. In practice this is almost never a problem since most people aren't foolish enough to reassign the value of undefined.

So, in a roundabout sort of way, you don't need to trap property accesses to return null for properties that have not been set so long as you compare the result against null using ==.

Bryan Kyle
A: 

Yes, but only in version 2.0 and higher. The exact syntax is still TBD but it's looking like it'll be get * () {...} for object literals at least.

Eli Grey