tags:

views:

635

answers:

5
+6  Q: 

ASP.NET - C# vs VB.NET - Indirect differences and things you might not initially consider

I'm not interested in starting another "who has the bigger member" VB vs C# debate (http://stackoverflow.com/questions/158229/what-are-the-pros-of-vb-net seems to cover that already) though I am interested in indirect differences which may influence developing in one vs the other. All my commercial .NET development was desktop apps in VB until the last 3 months where I had a web project and decided it was a good opportunity to force myself to learn C#. In the course of doing so I've noticed a few non-technical differences:

  • A lot more mature open source apps and thorough examples are available in C# than for VB.

  • Third party vendors of add-ins for things like refactoring and documentation tend to support C# better than VB (if at all), with VB support for similar features from comparable C# versions often lagging behind or absent.

  • ASP.NET jobs targeting C# seem to pay around 15-20% more on average than otherwise identical jobs in VB (at least in Australia, looking on seek.com.au and careerone.com.au for reference).

The jump to ASP.NET, MVC and C# presented a lot of speed humps at once but I think was well worth it. The decision I need to make now is whether to put more energy into pursuing C# for future .NET development or if I might as well stick to VB. Are there any other points of difference between the language (other than direct language feature comparisons already covered) that one should consider in this instance?

+1  A: 

I agree with your points, particularly the first. I would add that it seems there are more C# developers out there than VB.NET. If you are looking to hire another developer, you may get more (quantity or quality) from the C# pool. And employers, perceiving that C# is more popular, will go in that direction, and there will be more demand for C# programmers (hence the higher salaries/rates you noticed)

MikeW  2010-01-07 03:05:43
Lisa Feigenbaum, a Microsoft PM in the .NET Managed Languages Group, said (in June 2009) there are slightly more VB.NET developers than C#. http://www.infoq.com/news/2009/06/Future-VB.NET
MarkJ  2010-01-07 09:45:11
It may be a perception. I just checked jobs in New Zealand and got 16 hits for vb.net, and 102 for C#. That's open positions obviously, not developers. Maybe there *are* more VB.NET developers, meaning C# developers are more scarce and therefore more in demand?
MikeW  2010-01-07 20:01:05
I think the statement should be: there are more people who can/do use VB.NET, but more C# developers who are PROFESSIONALLY EMPLOYED. In thinking of it like that, I guess I can see a motivation for not accepting VB.NET applicants.
FerretallicA  2010-01-07 22:07:45
+3  A: 

I find that VS does more automatic code completion for VB than C#.

It's very useful to know both languages and I personally have to get better acquainted with C# so that I'm comfortable applying for C# jobs which should triple my options.

AUSteve  2010-01-07 03:07:22
Good point. One of the most frustrating things about moving to C# is the number of things VB picks up while you're coding which C# doesn't, resulting in a "code-compile-finderror-fix-repeat" cycle.
FerretallicA  2010-01-07 22:06:05
Using a tool like ReSharper can provide a lot of as-you're-typing assistance while learning C#.
Lance McNearney  2010-01-12 19:24:20
After many fruitless attempts at integrating programs like CodeRush into my workflow, ReSharper has finally won me over. Nice recommendation.
FerretallicA  2010-05-06 01:27:49
I like the back ground compilation feature of VB. Something which was lacking in C#. VS 2008 sp1 introduced it for C#. But still lacks when compared with back ground compilation feature of VB
Yogendra  2010-10-06 18:02:28
+2  A: 

One thing that has been widely stated when I have participated in hiring (both as a hiring manager, as well as a candidate) is that C# and Java are close enough that converting a candidate from one to the other is fairly easy, and that this is not true for a VB.NET candidate to C#, or Java. This statement has even been extended to C++, saying training a C# or Java developer (to code in C++) is easier than a VB.NET developer.

Though I tend to disagree (I think it is more about how the person sees programming in general) I know that several large, reputable firms will accept candidates for C# or Java jobs that list C++, C# or Java experience. These same firms will in general not look at candidates who only list VB.NET, or list VB.NET as their primary language.

GrayWizardx  2010-01-07 03:11:38
Can you list those firms, so we can avoid them? Sounds like their reputations are undeserved.
MarkJ  2010-01-07 09:42:17
That's actually a pretty good point for two reasons...1) When dealing with direct hiring not nearly so much as when dealing with recruitment agencies. All bar one recruitment agency I've dealt with for technical jobs had little idea what they were even asking in their own buzzword-laden advertisements. If they are told to look for "C#" and someone's resume says "C++" or even "C:)" I would imagine they'll bite.2) The pool of available learning materials is a lot greater if you are willing to put in the effort to adapt C/C++/Java examples/tutorials/etc.Accepted!
FerretallicA  2010-01-07 21:59:53
Its one reason why I encourage people to list their languages in one section (C, C++, Java, VB.NET) without years of experience and list their Experience in another section (projects, etc). Many firms use HR to process resumes before recruiters get them and the "filter" is looking for specific stuff (i.e. must have C experience, etc). A recruiter may know the experience is transferrable but the filterring person (HR, outsource firm, etc) may not.
GrayWizardx  2010-01-07 22:17:34
+3  A: 

  • At the Microsoft 2009 Mix Web developer conference, all the presentations that I attended included code examples in C#, not VB.

  • In StackOverflow, notice how questions tagged c# largely outnumber vb.net and vb.

  • John Skeet wrote C# in Depth, not VB in Depth.

James Lawruk  2010-01-07 03:57:05
+1 It's a consideration, although Microsoft have claimed (again) that VB.Net will be given equal status with C# in future
MarkJ  2010-01-07 09:46:02
VB in Depth would be about twice as big. VB, from a syntax and compiler standpoint, is a far more sophisticated language.
Jonathan Allen  2010-01-12 19:35:55
A: 

Specifically for web development, becoming proficient in C# made writing javascript (and doing complex things using jQuery) much easier because the syntax is so similar.

Lance McNearney  2010-01-12 18:47:02
Aside from == and the use of braces, C# and JavaScript are nothing alike.
Jonathan Allen  2010-01-12 19:37:19
I didn't say they were the same or even close... Just that the syntax is similar. For example braces, semi-colons, operator logic, if statements, switch cases, etc. It's much easier to switch back and forth between JS/C# vs JS/VB.
Lance McNearney  2010-01-12 19:55:44
Saying C# and JS are nothing alike is being ignorant, pedantic or both. I think it's a perfectly valid answer.
FerretallicA  2010-01-12 22:43:47

related questions

Displaying Flash content in a C# WinForms application
How to get the value of built, encoded ViewState?
Unhandled Exception Handler in .NET 1.1
How do I connect to a database and loop over a recordset in C#?
How do I most elegantly express left join with aggregate SQL as LINQ query
Get a new object instance from a Type in C#
.NET Testing Framework Advice
Automatically update version number
What is the difference between an int and an Integer in Java/C#?
How to write to Web.Config in Medium Trust ?
WinForms ComboBox data binding gotcha
How do you sort a C# dictionary by value?
Adding Scripting functionality to .NET applications
Floating Point Number parsing: Is there a Catch All algorithm?
How do I print an HTML document from a web service?
Decoding T-SQL CAST in C#/VB.net
Anatomy of a "Memory Leak"
How do I get a distinct, ordered list of names from a DataTable using Linq
Reliable Timer in a Console Application
How do I fill a DataSet or a DataTable from a LINQ query resultset ?
What's the difference between Math.Floor() and Math.Truncate() in .NET?
How do I calculate relative time?
How do I calculate someone's age in C#?
Are there any conversion tools for porting Visual J# code to C#?
When setting a form's opacity should I use a decimal or double?