views:

148

answers:

4

My question is why does the address of an array differ from the address of its first position?

I'm trying to write my own malloc, but to start out I'm just allocating a chunk of memory and playing around with the addresses. My code looks roughly like this:

#define BUFF_SIZE 1024
static char *mallocbuff;

int main(){
     mallocbuff = malloc(BUFF_SIZE);
     printf("The address of mallocbuff is %d\n", &mallocbuff);
     printf("The address of mallocbuff[0] is %d\n", &mallocbuff[0]);
}

&mallocbuff is the same address every time I run it. &mallocbuff[0] is some random address every time. I was expecting the addresses to match each other. Can anyone explain why this isn't the case?

+9  A: 

&mallocbuff is the address of the named variable mallocbuff. &mallocbuff[0] is the address of the first element in the buffer pointed to by mallocbuff, that you allocated with malloc().

anon
SB
@SB: It's probably too late for me to be up. Thanks for correcting me in my post.
Xavier Ho
+1  A: 

mallocbuff isn't an array, it's a pointer. It's stored completely separate from where malloc allocates.

This would give the results you expect (and as required):

int main(){
  char buf[1];
  printf("&buf    == %p\n", &buf);
  printf(" buf    == %p\n",  buf);  // 'buf' implicitly converted to pointer
  printf("&buf[0] == %p\n", &buf[0]);

  char* mbuf = buf;
  printf(" mbuf    == %p\n",  mbuf);
  printf("&mbuf[0] == %p\n", &mbuf[0]);

  printf("\n&mbuf(%p) != &buf(%p)\n", &mbuf, &buf);

  return 0;
}
Roger Pate
+2  A: 

When you take the address of mallocbuf (via &mallocbuf) you are not getting the address of the array - you are getting the address of a variable that points to the array.

If you want the address of the array just use mallocbuf itself (in the first printf()). This will return the same value as &mallocbuf[0]

Itay
A: 

Thanks all for the responses!

Remember to accept an answer! :]
Xavier Ho