[VB.Net] Typecasting generic parameters.

Question

Hello world!

Using the following code:

Function GetSetting(Of T)(ByVal SettingName As String, ByRef DefaultVal As T) As T
    Return If(Configuration.ContainsKey(SettingName), CType(Configuration(SettingName), T), DefaultVal)
End Function

Yields the following error:

Value of type 'String' cannot be converted to 'T'.

Any way I could specify that in all cases, the conversion will indeed be possible (I'm basically getting integers, booleans, doubles and strings).

Edit: There seem to be three solutions now:

• Using the `ValueAs` function provided by AMissico
• Casting to an `object`, then to `T`, with a check for null values
• Using a `DirectCast` over Convert.ChangeType

Which would you suggest?

Edit 2: Would this code work?

Function GetSetting(Of T)(ByVal SettingName As String, Optional ByRef DefaultVal As T = Nothing) As T
    Return If(Configuration.ContainsKey(SettingName), ConvertTo(Of T)(Configuration(SettingName)), DefaultVal)
End Function

Function ConvertTo(Of T)(ByVal Str As String) As T
    Return If(Str Is Nothing Or Str = "", Nothing, CType(CObj(Str), T))
End Function

Edit 3: [AMJ] Working Code

Function GetSetting(Of T)(ByVal SettingName As String) As T
    Return GetSetting(Of T)(SettingName, Nothing)
End Function
Function GetSetting(Of T)(ByVal SettingName As String, ByVal DefaultVal As T) As T
    Dim sValue As String = Configuration(SettingName)
    If Len(sValue) = 0 Then
        Return DefaultVal
    Else
        Return CType(CObj(sValue), T)
    End If
End Function

---

Quick Test Method

Public Sub DoIt()

    Me.Configuration.Add("KeyN", Nothing)
    Me.Configuration.Add("KeyE", String.Empty) '""
    Me.Configuration.Add("Key1", "99")
    Me.Configuration.Add("Key2", "1/1/2000")
    Me.Configuration.Add("Key3", "True")
    Me.Configuration.Add("Key4", "0")

    Dim o As Object 'using object in order to see what type is returned by methods

    o = Value(Of Integer)("KeyN", 10) '10
    o = Value(Of Integer)("KeyE", 10) '10
    o = Value(Of Integer)("Key1", 10) '99

    o = Value(Of Date)("KeyN", #11/11/2010#)
    o = Value(Of Date)("KeyE", #11/11/2010#)
    o = Value(Of Date)("Key2", #11/11/2010#)

    o = GetSetting(Of Integer)("KeyN", 10) '10
    o = GetSetting(Of Integer)("KeyE", 10) '10
    o = GetSetting(Of Integer)("Key1", 10) '99

    o = GetSetting(Of Date)("KeyN", #11/11/2010#)
    o = GetSetting(Of Date)("KeyE", #11/11/2010#)
    o = GetSetting(Of Date)("Key2", #11/11/2010#)

    Stop
End Sub

Answer 1

You need to put constraints on your method definition to constraint it to types that can be cast to string. See this for adding constraints to generics. You can only constrain to one classthough. I would constrain to object (becuase you can still specify t aas any type derived from the contraint type), then call ToString() instead of casting.

Answer 2

Is the type of Configuration a Dictionary<string, string> (c#)?
If yes, you don't need generics.

EDIT: If the Configuration(SettingsName) returns a string, the container is non-generic & hence you won't need generics here.

EDIT2:

void Main()
{
    Test<bool>.trythis("false");
    Test<bool>.trythis("true");
    Test<int>.trythis("28");
    Test<decimal>.trythis(decimal.MaxValue.ToString());
}

public class Test<T>
{
  public static void trythis(string value)
    {
        T retVal = (T)Convert.ChangeType(value, typeof(T));
        Console.WriteLine(retVal.GetType());
    }
}

I am sorry, I don't know vb.net enough.
It could be Convert.ChangeType(Configuration(SettingsName), T.GetType()) & then using a DirectCast over the results.

Hope this helps.

Answer 3

This requires a bit of hocus-pocus:

Public Function GetSetting(Of T As IConvertible)(ByVal SettingName As String, ByRef DefaultVal As T) As T
    Dim formatter As IFormatProvider = CultureInfo.InvariantCulture
    Dim targetType As Type = GetType(T)

    Dim value As IConvertible = Nothing
    Return If(Configuration.TryGetValue(SettingName, value), _
        DirectCast(value.ToType(targetType, formatter), T), _
        DefaultVal)
End Function

This code uses reflection to invoke the appropriate conversion method from the IConvertible interface that all basic value types implement. The result of this conversion can be cast using DirectCast.

Simplified: This code uses the ToType method, hence doesn’t require reflection.

Note that the IConvertible type constraint isn’t even strictly necessary here – since we call the IConvertible method on the String return value of the configuration, not the actual type. But the constraint is still useful since this ensures that the appropriate conversion will exist.

Answer 4

The Value(Of T) and ValueAs methods support nullable-types. I used Microsoft .NET 2.0 source code as a reference.

This is well-tested and production ready code.

There is no error handling in these "library" functions. It is the responsibility of the caller to handle any conversion errors that occur. The only conversion errors generated are obvious errors, such as trying to convert the string "abc" to Integer.

---

Public Sub DoIt()
    Dim o As Object
    o = Value(Of Integer)("foo", 10)
    o = Value(Of DateTime)("xxx", #1/1/2000#)
    o = Value(Of Boolean?)("nop", True)
    Stop
End Sub

Public Function GatherTag(ByVal tag As String) As String
    If tag = "foo" Then
        Return "99"
    Else
        Return String.Empty
    End If
End Function

''' <summary>
''' Provides strongly-typed access to the tag values. The method also supports nullable types.
''' </summary>
''' <typeparam name="T">A generic parameter that specifies the return type.</typeparam>
''' <param name="tag">The ExifTool Tag Name,</param>
''' <returns>The value, of type T, of the tag.</returns>
Public Function Value(Of T)(ByVal tag As String, ByVal defaultValue As T) As T
    Return DirectCast(ValueAs(GetType(T), tag, defaultValue), T)
End Function

''' <summary>
''' Returns the tag's value as the specified type. The method also supports nullable types.
''' </summary>
''' <param name="type">The type to return the tag value as.</param>
''' <param name="tag">The ExifTool Tag Name,</param>
''' <returns>The value of the tag as the type requested.</returns>
Public Function ValueAs(ByVal type As System.Type, ByVal tag As String, ByVal defaultValue As Object) As Object
    Dim oResult As Object = Nothing

    Dim oTag As String = GatherTag(tag)

    If Len(oTag) = 0 Then

        'use specified default value

        oResult = defaultValue

    Else

        'is requested type a generic type?

        If type.IsGenericType AndAlso type.GetGenericTypeDefinition Is GetType(Nullable(Of )) Then

            Dim oUnderlyingType As Type = Nullable.GetUnderlyingType(type)

            Dim oConstructed As Type = type.GetGenericTypeDefinition.MakeGenericType(oUnderlyingType)

            Dim oValue As Object

            oValue = System.Convert.ChangeType(oTag, oUnderlyingType)

            If oValue IsNot Nothing Then
                oResult = Activator.CreateInstance(oConstructed, oValue)
            End If

        Else

            'non-generic type

            oResult = System.Convert.ChangeType(oTag, type)

        End If

    End If

    Return oResult
End Function

Answer 5

Public Function Value(Of T)(ByVal SettingName As String, ByVal DefaultValue As T) As T
    Return If(Configuration.ContainsKey(SettingName), DirectCast(System.Convert.ChangeType(Configuration(SettingName), GetType(T)), T), DefaultValue)
End Function

Answer 6

Easy, just make it forget that it has a string by casting it to an object first.

Function GetSetting(Of T)(ByVal SettingName As String, ByRef DefaultVal As T) As T
    Return If(Configuration.ContainsKey(SettingName), CType(CObj(Configuration(SettingName)), T), DefaultVal)
End Function