How do I create a cross reference table/query for my data?

Question

I have two simple tables in my database. A "card" table that contains Id, Name, and text of a card, and a "rulings" table which contains the Id of the card, and text detailing the rulings for the card.

Often enough in the ruling text, there is a reference to another card in the database. It is easy enough to find this in the text because each card is encapsulated within quotes in the text. It is not uncommon to have multiple cards referenced within the text of the ruling.

What I'd like to do is be able to create a cross reference table (or procedure if it is efficient enough) so that when I submit a query for a card, I can find all the ruling records that directly reference the card through the Id and get all of the ruling records where the card name is referenced in the text.

What would be the best way to approach this? My environment is SQL 2005, but any kind of "DB agnostic" solutions are greatly accepted here.

Answer 1

I would recommend that you create another table that stores your references. Then, create an insert and update trigger that maintains this table. This way, you would have a faster query to return the data you are looking for.

I recognize that initially populating this table might be a little difficult, which is why I am showing some sample data (and query) below, that you can use to get you started.

Declare @Card Table(Id Int, Name VarChar(20), CardText VarChar(8000))

Declare @Ruling Table(CardId Int, CardRuling VarChar(8000))

Insert Into @Card Values(1, 'Card 1', 'This is the card ID = 1')
Insert Into @Card Values(2, 'Card 2', 'This is the card id = 2.')
Insert Into @Card Values(3, 'Card 3', 'This is the card id = 3.')

Insert Into @Ruling Values(1, 'This is the ruling for 1 which references "2"')
Insert Into @Ruling Values(2, 'This is the ruling for 2 which references nothing')
Insert Into @Ruling Values(3, 'This is the ruling for 3 which references "1" and "2"')

Declare @CardId Int
Set @CardId = 1

Select  * 
From    @Card As Card
        Inner Join @Ruling As Ruling
      On Card.Id = Ruling.CardId
     Left Join @Card As CardReferences
      On Ruling.CardRuling Like '%"' + Convert(VarChar(10), CardReferences.Id) + '"%'

EDIT:

The reason I suggested another table is because you will likely be disappointed with the performance of this query, especially for large tables.

Answer 2

This seems like a fairly simple and common relational problem that is solved by a cross-reference table. For example:

CREATE TABLE dbo.Cards (
    id        INT            NOT NULL,
    name      VARCHAR(50)    NOT NULL,
    card_text VARCHAR(4000)  NOT NULL,
    CONSTRAINT PK_Cards PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED (id)
)
GO
CREATE TABLE dbo.Card_Rulings (
    card_id        INT            NOT NULL,
    ruling_number  INT            NOT NULL,
    ruling_text    VARCHAR(4000)  NOT NULL,
    CONSTRAINT PK_Card_Rulings PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED (card_id, ruling_number)
)
GO
CREATE TABLE dbo.Card_Ruling_Referenced_Cards (
    parent_card_id    INT    NOT NULL,
    ruling_number     INT    NOT NULL,
    child_card_id     INT    NOT NULL,
    CONSTRAINT PK_Card_Ruling_Referenced_Cards PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED (parent_card_id, ruling_number, child_card_id)
)
GO
ALTER TABLE dbo.Card_Rulings
ADD CONSTRAINT FK_CardRulings_Cards FOREIGN KEY (card_id) REFERENCES dbo.Cards(id)
GO
ALTER TABLE dbo.Card_Ruling_Referenced_Cards
ADD CONSTRAINT FK_CardRulingReferencedCards_CardRulings FOREIGN KEY (parent_card_id, ruling_number) REFERENCES dbo.Card_Rulings (card_id, ruling_number)
GO
ALTER TABLE dbo.Card_Ruling_Referenced_Cards
ADD CONSTRAINT FK_CardRulingReferencedCards_Cards FOREIGN KEY (child_card_id) REFERENCES dbo.Cards(id)
GO

To get all card rulings for a card:

SELECT *
FROM dbo.Cards C
INNER JOIN dbo.Card_Rulings CR ON CR.card_id = C.id
WHERE C.id = @card_id

To get all cards referenced in a ruling by a given card:

SELECT C.*
FROM dbo.Card_Rulings CR
INNER JOIN dbo.Card_Ruling_Referenced_Cards CRRC ON CRRC.parent_card_id = CR.card_id
INNER JOIN dbo.Cards C ON C.id = CRRC.child_card_id
WHERE CR.card_id = @card_id

This was all off the top of my head and is not tested, so there might be syntactic errors, etc.

Your front end would be responsible for maintaining the references. This is probably desirable since it avoids the issue of someone forgetting to put quotes around a card name in a ruling text, etc.