views:

96

answers:

5

I would expect this line of JavaScript:

"foo bar baz".match(/^(\s*\w+)+$/)

to return something like:

["foo bar baz", "foo", " bar", " baz"]

but instead it returns only the last captured match:

["foo bar baz", " baz"]

Is there a way to get all the captured matches?

+1  A: 

How's about this? "foo bar baz".match(/(\w+)+/g)

meder
Your code works, but adding a global flag to my example won't solve the problem: "foo bar baz".match(/^(\s*\w+)+$/g) will return ["foo bar baz"]
Discodancer
A: 

Unless you have a more complicated requirement for how you're splitting your strings, you can split them, and then return the initial string with them:

var data = "foo bar baz";
var pieces = data.split(' ');
pieces.unshift(data);
g.d.d.c
+3  A: 

When you repeat a capturing group, in most flavors, only the last capture is kept; any previous capture is overwritten. In some flavor, e.g. .NET, you can get all intermediate captures, but this is not the case with Javascript.

That is, in Javascript, if you have a pattern with N capturing groups, you can only capture exactly N strings per match, even if some of those groups were repeated.

So generally speaking, depending on what you need to do:

  • If it's an option, split on delimiters instead
  • Instead of matching /(pattern)+/, maybe match /pattern/g, perhaps in an exec loop
    • Do note that these two aren't exactly equivalent, but it may be an option
  • Do multilevel matching:
    • Capture the repeated group in one match
    • Then run another regex to break that match apart

References


Example

Here's an example of matching <some;words;here> in a text, using an exec loop, and then splitting on ; to get individual words (see also on ideone.com):

var text = "a;b;<c;d;e;f>;g;h;i;<no no no>;j;k;<xx;yy;zz>";

var r = /<(\w+(;\w+)*)>/g;

var match;
while ((match = r.exec(text)) != null) {
  print(match[1].split(";"));
}
// c,d,e,f
// xx,yy,zz

The pattern used is:

      _2__
     /    \
<(\w+(;\w+)*)>
 \__________/
      1

This matches <word>, <word;another>, <word;another;please>, etc. Group 2 is repeated to capture any number of words, but it can only keep the last capture. The entire list of words is captured by group 1; this string is then split on the semicolon delimiter.

Related questions

polygenelubricants
This is an awesome answer. I'm gonna go with splitting by delimiters. Thanks.
Discodancer
A: 

I'm surprised that @meder's solution doesn't satisfy your question. But if you want to get back exactly ["foo bar baz","foo","bar","baz"], I don't think a general solution will help you. How about this:

"foo bar baz".match(/(\w+)\s(\w+)\s(\w+)/)
Andrew
Except that I don't know how many \w+ tokens I have in the string. @polygenelubricants answers my question pretty good.
Discodancer
In that case, I agree. @polygenelubricant's answer is excellent.
Andrew
A: 

try using 'g':

"foo bar baz".match(/\w+/g)
Jet