Redundant __packed__ attributes

Question

This code is for Microchip's PIC32MX microprocessor. Their compiler is essentially GCC 3.4.

I tend use GCC's __packed__ attribute to pack bitfields into a union, and later retrieve them as an unsigned char (ie. type-punning) for sending over SPI or I2C. This behaviour is all defined by my implementation, and works perfectly. I prefer this to a hundred or so lines of masking and shifting :)

My question is: are there __packed__ attributes in the code below that are redundant? At first glance, I would think that those on the top-level union members can be dispensed with, but I'm not so sure. Or can I leave out those in the nested struct?

// Remember that bitfields cannot straddle word boundaries!
typedef struct
{
    /// Some flag #1
    unsigned FlagOne            : 1 __attribute__((packed));
    /// Some flag #2
    unsigned FlagTwo            : 1 __attribute__((packed));
    /// A chunk of data
    unsigned SomeData           : 5 __attribute__((packed));

    // and so on, maybe up to 32 bits long depending on the destination

} BlobForSomeChip;

/// This kind of type-punning is implementation defined. Read Appendix A (A7, A12) of
/// the MPLAB C Compiler for PIC32 MCUs manual.
typedef union
{
    /// Access the members of this union to set flags, etc
    BlobForSomeChip blobdata __attribute__((packed));

    /// As a byte for sending via SPI, I2C etc
    unsigned char bytes[4] __attribute__((packed));

} BlobData;

Answer 1

First of all, I recommend compiling with -Wall.

Now:

1. The BlobForSomeChip struct has 7 bits declared. Normally, it would be 4 bytes long due to alignment, but with packed attributes it will be only 1 byte long.
2. A unsigned char[4] can't be packed. It will always be 4 bytes long, no matter what.

In short:

1. struct BlobForSomeChip = 1 byte
2. unsigned char[4] = 4 bytes
3. BlobData = 4 bytes (its largest member's size).

Concluding, the packed attributes on BlobData are not required. GCC will simply ignore them if used - see the output using -Wall.