Your metatag examples didn't render (you probably didn't put them in a code block)... but I'm assuming they were showing a different og:image tag returned based on the querystring passed in.
I appreciate your help, but this isn't quite what we want. Yes, the Facebook servers call back to get the page (and metatags), but the UI pressented to the user shows the ability to select more than one thumbnail.
Right now all our pages show "Thumbnail (1 of 1)" and have the thumbnail selector buttons greyed out. So, I was hoping that there would be a way to list multiple og:image tags, or have one og:image with multiple delimited images within it.
Having the querystring doesn't really work, as that would require the user choosing the thumbnail before clicking through to sharer.php.
And we did look at the Graph API, but have discounted this as it seems to make sharing too hard for the user. Asking users to accept a "trust our site" Facebook dialog in order to directly post to their pages doesn't seem like a good idea.
If anyone knows if it's possible to on a single page to have metatags formatted in such a way that Facebook sharer.php can give the user the option of choosing from more than one thumbnail, it would be appreciated!