Wrapping an existing EXE into an MSI - drawbacks?

Question

We've got an EXE which works great for installing our application. However, we have multiple customers who are requesting an MSI for ease of deployment in their current domain.

If we use our existing EXE install process, can we wrap that into an MSI and expect good results? The EXE creates an "Uninstall" that is added to the control panel's uninstall list... will the MSI also generate an uninstall point, leaving us with two entries?

Is there anything else I should watch for?

Thanks

Answer 1

Your customers are probably asking for MSIs so they can manipulate the MSI with the variety of tools that work only on MSIs. For example, there are deployment tools that are able to look at MSIs and only send down the changed files to a system when it gets a new version of the MSI. These work off the file table in the MSI. If you wrap your exe in a MSI, the only file in your MSI file table is the exe, which makes tools used to manipulate the files you are installing, useless.