How to extract some data from a collection using lambda/linq to objects?

Question

Hi folks,

i have an IList<Animals> farmAnimals;

this list has three types,

• Cows
• Sheep
• Chickens

how can i remove all the Chickens from the list using a lambda query or linq-to-objects so i have a separate list of chickens and the original list now only has cows and sheep.

Do i have to make three lists (the original + 2 new ones, filtered) and then null the original list? or is there a trickier way?

result needs to be

IList<Aniamls> chickens;
IList<Animals> farmAnimals; // only contains the cows and sheep, now.

cheers!

CLARIFICATION QUESTION:

what is more performant? FindAll & RemoveAll versus the Where suggestion?

Answer 1

var chickens = farmAnimals.ToList().FindAll (c => c.Type == "Chicken");
farmAnimals.RemoveAll(a => a.Type=="Chicken");

Answer 2

var chickens = farmAnimals.Where(a => a.GetType() == typeof(Chicken)).ToList();
farmAnimals = farmAnimals.Where(a => a.GetType() != typeof(Chicken)).ToList();

Answer 3

var Chickens = farmAnimals.FindAll(a=>a is Chicken);

I have a terrible tendency to sway to the simplest solution possible. In this case, using the lambda only requires the .NET framework 2.0. The LINQ extension methods require 3.5.

Answer 4

Assuming:

public abstract class Animal {}

public class Chicken : Animal {}

you can do:

var chickens = animals.OfType<Chicken>().Cast<Animal>().ToList();

var nonChickens = animals.Except(chickens).ToList();

Edit

Any reasonable answer should be O(n), meaning each item in the original list is only processed once. Therefore, I would suggest an imperative approach:

var chickens = new List<Animal>();
var nonChickens = new List<Animal>();

foreach(var animal in animals)
{
    var list = animal is Chicken ? chickens : nonChickens;

    list.Add(animal);
}