tags:

views:

418

answers:

3

Wondering if there is any way to get the lambda expressions that result from a LINQ "query" syntax expression.

Given:

var query = from c in dc.Colors
            where c.ID == 213
            orderby c.Name, c.Description
            select new {c.ID, c.Name, c.Description };

Is there any way to get the generated "lambda" code / expression?

var query = dc.Colors
    .Where(c => c.ID == 213)
    .OrderBy(c => c.Name)
    .ThenBy(c => c.Description)
    .Select(c => new {c.ID, c.Name, c.Description, });

I know these are very simple examples and that the C# compiler generates a lambda expression from the query expression when compiling the code. Is there any way to get a copy of that expression?

I am hoping to use this as a training tool for some of my team members that aren't very comfortable with lambda expressions. Also, I have used Linq Pad, but ideally this can be accomplised without a 3rd party tool.

+3  A: 

You could try compiling the assembly and then having a look at it using Reflector.

This might be a bit more complicated than you want though, because the compiler will compile things right down to the direct method calls (everything will be static method calls, not extension methods, and the lambdas will get compiled into their own functions which are usually called something like <ClassName>b_88f)

You'll certainly figure out what's going on though :-)

Orion Edwards
Reflector is a wonderful tool! Bonus points because you can use it to look at the .net code for just about any .net assembly.
Chris Brandsma
+1  A: 

ReSharper has that feature. It will take a LINQ to Lambda and back again at the stroke of a key. Also very (very) useful for other things.

JP Alioto
Really trying to avoid 3rd party tools.
Andrew Robinson
+2  A: 

Simply go:

string lambdaSyntax = query.Expression.ToString();

The disadvantage compared to LINQPad is that the result is formatted all one line.

Joe Albahari
This produces similar results to those found by using Reflector on your assembly. All static method calls against crazy named anonymous types. Not ideal.
Andrew Robinson
It's better than what you see in Reflector - and it's as good as you'll get without third party tools.
Joe Albahari
Love your book. I bought a few copies for team members.
Andrew Robinson