Why does Decimal.Divide(int, int) work, but not (int / int)?

Question

How come dividing two 32 bit int numbers as ( int / int ) returns to me 0, but if I use Decimal.Divide() I get the correct answer? I'm by no means a c# guy.

Answer 1

int is an integer type; dividing two ints performs an integer division, i.e. the fractional part is truncated since it can't be stored in the result type (also int!). Decimal, by contrast, has got a fractional part. By invoking Decimal.Divide, your int arguments get implicitly converted to Decimals.

You can enforce non-integer division on int arguments by explicitly casting at least one of the arguments to a floating-point type, e.g.:

int a = 42;
int b = 23;
double result = (double)a / b;

Answer 2

If you are looking for 0 < a < 1 answer, int / int will not suffice. int / int does integer division. Try casting one of the int's to a double inside the operation.

Answer 3

I reckon Decimal.Divide(decimal, decimal) implicitly converts its 2 int arguments to decimals before returning a decimal value (precise) where as 4/5 is treated as integer division and returns 0

Answer 4

In the first case, you're doing integer division, so the result is truncated (the decimal part is chopped off) and an integer is returned.

In the second case, the ints are converted to decimals first, and the result is a decimal. Hence they are not truncated and you get the correct result.

Answer 5

The following line:

int a = 1, b = 2;
object result = a / b;

...will be performed using integer arithmetic. Decimal.Divide on the other hand takes two parameters of the type Decimal, so the division will be performed on decimal values rather than integer values. That is equivalent of this:

int a = 1, b = 2;
object result = (Decimal)a / (Decimal)b;

To examine this, you can add the following code lines after each of the above examples:

Console.WriteLine(result.ToString());
Console.WriteLine(result.GetType().ToString());

The output in the first case will be

0
System.Int32

..and in the second case:

0,5
System.Decimal