views:

3967

answers:

9

What are the other ways of achieving autoincrement in oracle other than use of triggers?

+1  A: 

Use a sequence

Gilles
+11  A: 

You can create and use oracle sequences. The syntax and details are at http://www.techonthenet.com/oracle/sequences.php

Also read the article http://rnyb2.blogspot.com/2006/02/potential-pitfall-with-oracle-sequence.html to understand the limitations with respect to AUTONUMBER in other RDBMS

Dheer
Exactly. Caching and rollbacks make this nearly impossible... +1.
Dan Vinton
+2  A: 

As far as I can recall from my Oracle days, you can't achieve Auto Increment columns without using TRIGGER. Any solutions out there to make auto increment column involves TRIGGER and SEQUENCE (I'm assuming you already know this, hence the no trigger remarks).

Salamander2007
Of course you can. You create an Insert procedure that gets the nextval. you revoke Insert on that table and grant execute on that proc/package. No trigger needed.
Why was this answer selected?
cletus
because it's true. You cannot do plain INSERT and achieve the same effect as autoincrement without the use of Trigger and Sequence. Mark Brady Answer is also true, if you consider Stored Proc as a plain insert.
Salamander2007
+1  A: 

If you don't need sequential numbers but only a unique ID, you can use a DEFAULT of SYS_GUID(). Ie:

CREATE TABLE xxx ( ID RAW(16) DEFAULT SYS_GUID() )
angus
Oooo, really good answer.
+6  A: 

A trigger to obtain the next value from a sequence is the most common way to achieve an equivalent to AUTOINCREMENT:

create trigger mytable_trg
before insert on mytable
for each row
when (new.id is null)
begin
    select myseq.nextval into :new.id from dual;
end;

You don't need the trigger if you control the inserts - just use the sequence in the insert statement:

insert into mytable (id, data) values (myseq.nextval, 'x');

This could be hidden inside an API package, so that the caller doesn't need to reference the sequence:

mytable_pkg.insert_row (p_data => 'x');

But using the trigger is more "transparent".

Tony Andrews
The trigger might generate a sequence value only if :new.id is NULL, this would more closely mimic auto-increment in other database brands.
Bill Karwin
Thanks, Bill - I have amended the trigger.
Tony Andrews
Note that you need a FOR EACH ROW or else :new is not accessible... or at least that's what my textbook said when I took a class in PL/SQL.
R. Bemrose
Thanks, I have added FOR EACH ROW clause now.
Tony Andrews
+1  A: 

Create a sequence:

create sequence seq;

Then to add a value

insert into table (id, other1, other2)
values (seq.nextval, 'hello', 'world');

Note: Look for oracle docs for more options about sequences (start value, increment, ...)

FerranB
A: 

select max(id)+1 from table

kedar kamthe
I think it's not really concurrent friendly
Salamander2007
"I think it's not really concurrent friendly" I'll second that. I've seen web applications that were coded this way do all sorts of interesting things...
RussellH
That's really worst practice. Never ever use such things.
Marius Burz
A: 
Reinier
A: 

Hi there. If you don't really want to use a "trigger-based" solution, you can achieve the auto-increment functionality with a programmatical approach, obtaining the value of the auto increment key with the getGeneratedKeys() method.

Here is a code snippet for your consideration:

Statement stmt = null;
ResultSet rs = null;

stmt = conn.createStatement(java.sql.ResultSet.TYPE_FORWARD_ONLY,
                                java.sql.ResultSet.CONCUR_UPDATABLE);

stmt.executeUpdate("DROP TABLE IF EXISTS autoIncTable");

stmt.executeUpdate("CREATE TABLE autoIncTable ("
                + "priKey INT NOT NULL AUTO_INCREMENT, "
                + "dataField VARCHAR(64), PRIMARY KEY (priKey))");

stmt.executeUpdate("INSERT INTO autoIncTable  (dataField) "
                + "values ('data field value')",
                Statement.RETURN_GENERATED_KEYS);

int autoIncKeyFromApi = -1;

rs = stmt.getGeneratedKeys();

if (rs.next()) {
    autoIncKeyFromApi = rs.getInt(1);
}
else {
    // do stuff here        
}

rs.close();

source: http://forums.oracle.com/forums/thread.jspa?messageID=3368856

XpiritO