String object versus literal - modifying the prototype?

Question

Hi All,

I'm wondering why it seems that adding a method to the prototype of a string literal seems to work, but adding a property does not? I was playing with ideas in relation to this question, and have the following code:

String.prototype._str_index1 = 0;
String.prototype._str_reset = function() {
    this._str_index1 = 0;
};
String.prototype._str_substr = function(len) {
  var ret = this.substr(this._str_index1, len);
  this._str_index1 = this._str_index1 + len;
  return ret;
};

var testString = new String('Loremipsumdolorsitamet,consectetur');
log(testString._str_substr(5));
log(testString._str_substr(4));
​

This works fine. If however I change the third-last line to:

var testString = 'Loremipsumdolorsitamet,consectetur';

...it seems that although the method _str_substr exists and is callable on the string literal, the value of the property _str_index1 is always 0.

What's up?

Answer 1

This happens because the object is created and immediately thrown away when the assignment is made, because it's a string literal.

So with the first version, an object is created and kept, so testString is an object, not a string literal. In the second case, an object is created and thrown away, so all properties get lost...

Now try replacing that line with this:

var testString = 'Loremipsumdolorsitamet,consectetur'._str_substr();

Interesting, right? It still returns a string primitive, but that could be fixed...

String.prototype._str_substr = function(len) {
  var ret = this.substr(this._str_index1, len);
  this._str_index1 = this._str_index1 + len;
  return new String(ret);
};

Of course these are just suggestions designed to help explain why literals act differently than objects, not real-world recommendations...

Answer 2

The string primitive is converted to a transient String object every time you try to invoke a method of the String object (the JavaScript engine internally converts a string primitive to a String object when necessary). After this function returns, the String object is (unobtrusively) converted back to a string primitive (under the hood) and this new primitive is returned (and most of the time assigned to a variable); every time a method of the String object is invoked.

So, after each invocation of testString._str_substr, _str_index1 is thrown away with the object and a new object (with a reset _str_index1) is created when _str_substr is called again.

See also MDC:

Because JavaScript automatically converts between string primitives and String objects, you can call any of the methods of the String object on a string primitive. JavaScript automatically converts the string primitive to a temporary String object, calls the method, then discards the temporary String object.