tags:

views:

744

answers:

6

I have a form where depending on the website's brand one of two input fields should be visible at one given spot.

I figured I just put both input fields in the same container and then through my stylesheet set one of them to display:none; This does hide the field, but it still makes it take up space. I also tried setting the height and width to 0 or setting visibility to hidden or collapse but none of those worked.

Untill now all the branding things could be done with css style sheets so I would like to keep it that way. The solution should at least be supported in IE6 & up, Firefox 2 & up and Chrome (latest).

A: 

I'm not too familiar with CSS, but you can try implementing JQuery which combines Javascript and CSS to let you do stuff like that with relative ease.

Maxim Zaslavsky
I know, but if possible I would rather not rely on JS as it will also run on no-JS machines.
borisCallens
Oh okay! I'm a newbie at StackOverflow, so should I delete my answer? Thanks!
Maxim Zaslavsky
No, just keep as is. It is a valid answer, just not the best one ;)
borisCallens
+1  A: 

why not input type="hidden" ?

adrien334
This would be good. Ideally the HTML presented to the user should make sense without the need for CSS.
edeverett
This would spread my branding logic over the stylesheet and the views. Now I need to maintain branding logic at two places instead of one.
borisCallens
Muddling the separation of concerns in the technologies you are using for quick gains is rarely the path to easily maintainable code.
edeverett
And how do you see your sentence connected to my case? Stylesheets are for GUI definition. The branding is pure GUI. The functionality is exactly the same. There is no quick gain involved. The quick gain is having conditional rendering. Now whenever a brand is added I have to make sure my conditional rendering takes the new brand into account as well.
borisCallens
A: 
<style>
.hideme
{
    display:none;
    visibility:hidden;
}
.showme
{
    display:inline;
    visibility:visible;
}
</style>


<input type="text" name="mytext" class="hideme">

You can either set class="hideme" to hide your control or class="showme" to show your control. You can set this toggeling using JavaScript or server side coding.

Bhaskar
It's visibility: hidden, not visible: false, and it'svisibility: visible, not visible: true.
Joe Chung
yes, right...sorry...it wass a typo
Bhaskar
Please refer to the last sentence of the second paragraph in my post
borisCallens
And your code still says visible instead of visibility
borisCallens
today is definately not my day....fixed it...:)
Bhaskar
+2  A: 

This does hide the field, but it still makes it take up space.

This shouldn't happen; display: none should cause the element to not be included in the flow. Check the rest of your CSS (try using Firebug to figure out where the extra "space", which is probably just padding or margin of some surrounding element, is coming from).

Rahul
I think, this is the only way you can do this using CSS (as the question suggests)...
Bhaskar
A: 

Using the visibility property takes up rendering space even if the element is not visible. Instead of using visivility you have to use display property.

You can set the display to none if you want to hide the element and display to block or inline if you want to show them.

To have a look on display check this

If setting your display property doesn't solve your problem, then I think the textboxes might be absolutely positioned. It might be the reason for the layout not to be changed.

Can you please post the complete code?

rahul
+1  A: 

What about setting the invisible input field to position: absolute; which should take it out of the rendering flow.

However, setting it to display: none should in theory do the same...

peirix
Display:none didn't do the trick. In combination with position:absolute it did though. You think you can provide me with an explanation as of why?
borisCallens
position: absolute will take any element out of the render flow, making it have no impact on any other element around it. It's a very common method for overlays and modals.
peirix