views:

1523

answers:

9

Can anyone tell the difference between mysqli->commit and mysqli::commit?

The header in this page is mysqli::commit but

in examples they use mysqli->commit

I'm confused.

A: 

:: accesses the class' function without instancing an object.

envalid
+3  A: 

:: is used for static methods

-> is used for method of an object if you already have the instance

easement
A: 

The -> operator is for object properties an the :: operator is for class properties.

Gumbo
A: 

in mysqli->commit, mysqli is a instance of MySQLi in mysqli::commit call a static method

andres descalzo
+1  A: 

If you have an instance of an object, you use -> to refer to a method inside this instance:

$foo = new Foo();
$foo->bar();

Using :: calls a static method without having to create an instance of the object:

Foo::baz();

A static method cannot refer to an it's current instance through $this, but can refer to itself (current class) by using self.

sixfoottallrabbit
Calling a non-static member using the scope resolution operator raises an E_STRICT in PHP < 5.3.0 and an E_WARNING in PHP >= 5.3.0.
Andrew Moore
And `self` exists to refer to the current class in a static context. It doesn't refer to an instance, but to itself: `class A { static function b() { self::c(); } private static function c() { echo 'hello'; } };`
Andrew Moore
A: 

mysqli->commit is a public function and mysqli::commit is a static function the two are php object notations of mysqli class.

Houssem
A: 

usually in php.net documentation :: means that this class has that method. For pratical usage you must follow the example so use the -> sintax.

mck89
A: 

:: specifies a static (class) method, which is callable without actually instantiating an object. -> specifies an instance (object) method, for which you need an object instantiated to be able to use.

So for example, if you had a variable $m which was an instance of class mysqli, you would call commit by saying $m->commit(), or you could call commit statically by saying MySQLi::commit()

Daniel Vandersluis
+17  A: 

-> is used when referring to a member of an object.

:: is the Scope Resolution Operator and is used to refer to a static member of a Class.

Consider the following class:

class FooBar {
    public static function fizz() {
        echo "Fizz";
    }

    public function buzz() {
        echo "Buzz";
    }
}

You would call the function buzz() using ->:

$myFooBar = new FooBar();
$myFooBar->buzz();

But would use :: to call the functon fizz(), as it is a static member (a member which doesn't require an instance of the class to be called):

FooBar::fizz();


Also, while we are talking about the difference between static members versus instantiated members, you cannot use $this to refer to the current instance within static members. You use self instead (no leading $) which refers to the current class, or parent if you want to refer to the parent class, or if you have the pleasure of working with PHP 5.3.0, static (which allows for late static binding).


The documentation uses :: to refer to a function inside a class as the class name in the header is not an instance of the class. Still using the same example, a documentation entry referring to the function buzz() would use the following header:

FooBar::buzz

But unless the documentation specifies it's a static member, you will need to use -> on an instance to call it:

$myFooBar = new FooBar();
$myFooBar->buzz();
Andrew Moore
Was about to post, but this is pretty spot on. In short answer to John there is no difference. As Andrew states its a convention in the PHP manual to describe a class method as ClassName::methodNameThe intention is to use is as an object, i.e. $name->commit() unless it says otherwise in the documentation.
simonrjones
well typed answer. very helpful.
easement