Android: How to initialize MediaRecorder without a valid surface for video preview?

Question

Hello all,

I am building a camera app, where videos are continuously being captured and saved to the SD card. The videos are short (few minutes), and their length are preset with setMaxDuration().

The whole process works fine, while the main activity is in the foreground. But, when I go to another activity (e.g. settings), the video recording works in the background only until max duration is reached. The file is saved, but a new sequence can not be started because prepare() fails, apparently because setPreviewDisplay() doesn't like not having a proper surface to attach to.

I tried to use a dummy Surface, a dummy SurfaceHolder, lockCanvas(), and various other tricks, but nothing works. Is there a way to initialize MediaRecorder without a valid surface?

Thanks and regards, Robert

Answer 1

Oops, I have a feeling we are working on a similar application LOL. I am stuck with the same exact problem.

Answer 2

Are you implementing Surface callbacks?

Why do you need to initialize MediaRecorder without a valid surface?

Are you supposed to be recording even when you leave the main activity? or does recording stop before the other acitivty is spawned?

Answer 3

Unfortunately it is still a requirement for you to preview onto a valid surface in order to record video (Android SDK 1.6 thru 2.2). There is an enhancement request logged to remove this restriction http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=9570