There are no responseText1 and responseText2 properties of an XMLHTTPRequest(which I assume your xmlHttp is), just responseText, so you have to return something parsable in that responseText field(like JSON). So you server may send back {"firstResponse":"value1","secondResponse":"value2"} and you can fill your fields from that JSON string. Use the json2.js library from json.org
<script type="text/javascript" src="json2.js"></script>
. . .
var theResponse = JSON.parse(xmlHttp.responseText);
document.getElementById('nr1').innerHTML = theResponse.firstResponse;
document.getElementById('nr2').innerHTML = theResponse.secondResponse;
EDIT:
In order to craft this JSON response from PHP you should use the PHP JSON libraries. There are several examples in the json_encode page that can get you started. The other code I posted(and that is posted in other responses) are all browser side javascript code.
$arr = array ('firstResponse'=>'value1','secondResponse'=>'value2');
echo json_encode($arr);
Place that code into your PHP script to generate the JSON string
{"firstResponse":"value1","secondResponse":"value2"}
Then the previously posted javascript code will parse that.