System.LINQ.Dynamic: Select(" new (...)") into a List<T> (or any other enumerable collection of <T>)

Question

Hi All,

Say I have a DataTable with four columns, Company (string), Fund (string), State (string), Value(double):

    table1.Rows.Add("Company 1","Fund 1","NY",100));
    table1.Rows.Add("Company 2","Fund 1","CA",200));
    table1.Rows.Add("Company 3","Fund 1","FL",300));
    table1.Rows.Add("Company 4","Fund 2","CA",400));
    table1.Rows.Add("Company 5","Fund 1","NY",500));
    table1.Rows.Add("Company 6","Fund 2","CA",600));
    table1.Rows.Add("Company 7","Fund 3","FL",700));

I want to use System.LINQ.Dynamic to build a dynamic query which groups on either Company, Fund, or State, and then selects my group by criteria as the first column, and sum(value):

string groupbyvalue="Fund";
var q1= table1.AsEnumerable().AsQueryable
              .groupby(groupbyvalue,"it")
              .Select("new ("+groupbyvalue+" as Group, Sum(Value) as TotalValue)");

In the above query, the selected groupbyvalue (Group) will always be a string, and the sum will always be a double, so I want to be able to cast into something like a List, where Result is an object with properties Group (string) and TotalValue (double).

I'm having a lot of trouble with this, can anyone shed some light?

Answer 1

First, you'll access the current grouped value as Key in your Select clause:

.Select("new (Key as Group, Sum(Value) as TotalValue)");

That should make your query work. The harder question is how to turn the returned objects, which will have a dynamically generated type that inherits from DynamicClass, into a static type.

Option 1: Use reflection to access the dynamic object's Group and TotalValue properties.

Option 2: Use compiled expression trees for lightweight code generation to access the Group and TotalValue properties.

Option 3: Modify the Dynamic library to support a strongly-typed result. This turns out to be rather simple:

1. In ExpressionParser.Parse(), capture the type argument in a private field:

   private Type newResultType;
   public Expression Parse(Type resultType)
   {
       newResultType = resultType;
       int exprPos = token.pos;
       // ...
   

2. Near the end of ExpressionParser.ParseNew(), we'll try to use newResultType before defaulting to a dynamic type:

   Expression ParseNew()
   {
       // ...
       NextToken();
       Type type = newResultType ?? DynamicExpression.CreateClass(properties);
       MemberBinding[] bindings = new MemberBinding[properties.Count];
       for (int i = 0; i < bindings.Length; i++)
           bindings[i] = Expression.Bind(type.GetProperty(properties[i].Name), expressions[i]);
       return Expression.MemberInit(Expression.New(type), bindings);
   }
   

3. Finally, we need a strongly typed version of Select():

   public static IQueryable<TResult> Select<TResult>(this IQueryable source, string selector, params object[] values)
   {
       if (source == null) throw new ArgumentNullException("source");
       if (selector == null) throw new ArgumentNullException("selector");
       LambdaExpression lambda = DynamicExpression.ParseLambda(source.ElementType, typeof(TResult), selector, values);
       return source.Provider.CreateQuery<TResult>(
           Expression.Call(
               typeof(Queryable), "Select",
               new Type[] { source.ElementType, typeof(TResult) },
               source.Expression, Expression.Quote(lambda)));
   }
   

   The only changes from the original Select() are places we reference TResult.

Now we just need a named type to return:

    public class Result
    {
        public string Group { get; set; }
        public double TotalValue { get; set; }
    }

And your updated query will look like this:

    IQueryable<Result> res = table1.AsQueryable()
        .GroupBy(groupbyvalue, "it")
        .Select<Result>("new (Key as Group, Sum(Value) as TotalValue)");

Answer 2

Simply brilliant, modified the dynamic library and it works... even more important, I learned something about how the dynamic parser works! Many Thanks