What are the advantages and disadvantages in MVC patterns when it's using in Java?
+4
A:
Advantages and Disadvantages of any design pattern do not depend on any language!
Megadix
2009-10-06 07:24:31
I slightly disagree. Some design pattern are harder/clunkier to implement in some languages and simply unnecessary in others (Examples: 1. Strategy pattern can become unwieldly in Java, due to the verbose nature of anonymous classes. 2. Visitor pattern is not necessary in languages that support multiple dispatch (LISP)).
Joachim Sauer
2009-10-06 07:45:43
I agree with you, for *some* pattern language does matter, but I think they are just a minority
Megadix
2009-10-08 09:31:04
+2
A:
I think the answer is independent of the language and even the first line of Wikipedia answers it quite well: "The pattern isolates business logic from input and presentation, permitting independent development, testing and maintenance of each." Wikipedia: Model-view-controller
sfussenegger
2009-10-06 07:25:36
A:
MVC Pattern is widely used in Java. Most of the java web frameworks are built on MVC architecture. As stated in a previous reply "Advantages and Disadvantages of any design pattern do not depend on any language". This is 90% percent true.
JSP is well fitted for MVC Pattern. The JSP architecture has a lot of features and concepts that makes MVC easily implementable in Java, and a few classes suitable for MVC: ServletController to be used in the controller layer, JSP files to be used in presentation layer; controller can delegate the calls to other controllers, of to jsp pages.
However, JSP is just an java "extension", does not represent java core. Writing a new MVC framework from scratch is possible, and there are many java JSP alternatives out there, many based on MVC(Struts2/WebWorks for example).
Writing a new MVC framework from scratch in java is (almost) as easy/hard as writing it in another language.
php html
2010-07-13 11:03:25