Better to save a slug to the DB or generate dynamically?

Question

Hi - I am working on a django project and would like to include a slug at the end of the url, as is done here on stackoverflow.com: http://example.com/object/1/my-slug-generated-from-my-title

The object ID will be used to look up the item, not the slug -- and, like stackoverflow.com, the slug won't matter at all when getting the link (just in displaying it).

Qestion: is there a downside (or upside) to generating the slug dynamically, rather than saving it as an actual database field ?

For example (not real code):

class Widget(models.Model):
    title = models.CharField()

    def _slug(self):
      return slugify(self.title)
    slug = property(_slug)

Rather than using an something like an AutoSlugField (for example) ?

Since my plan is to have it match the title, I didn't know if it made sense to have a duplicate field in the database.

Thanks!

Answer 1

If you're using the slug for decorative (rather than lookup) purposes, generating it dynamically is the best idea.

Additionally, the code sample you posted can be written like this:

@property
def slug(self):
  return slugify(self.title)

Answer 2

The downside would be that you're automatically generating the slug every time you render the page. The upside is that you're not taking up space in the database with a field that will never be directly queried against.

Either way is fine, it just depends on your performance vs. space requirements.

Answer 3

The main downside of generating slugs dynamically is that you miss the ability to customize slugs per-object, eg. make them shorter and prettier. For English titles this can be OK, but for non-English content generated slugs can be ugly.

Answer 4

Try making a slug out of the word "café" or "浦安鉄筋家族".

Chances are that it'll look like poo, unless you're really well-prepared.

Sometimes you need the ability to customize slugs.