tags:

views:

15835

answers:

19

I have a new app I'll be working on where I have to generate a Word document that contains tables, graphs, a table of contents and text. What's a good API to use for this? How sure are you that it supports graphs, ToCs, and tables? What are some hidden gotcha's in using them?

Some clarifications:

  • I can't output a PDF, they want a Word doc.
  • They're using MS Word 2003 (or 2007), not OpenOffice
  • Application is running on *nix app-server

It'd be nice if I could start with a template doc and just fill in some spaces with tables, graphs, etc.

Thanks for the help.

Edit: Several good answers below, each with their own faults as far as my current situation. Hard to pick a "final answer" from them. Think I'll leave it open, and hope for better solutions to be created.

Edit: The OpenOffice UNO project does seem to be closest to what I asked for. While POI is certainly more mainstream, it's too immature for what I want.

+13  A: 

I think Apache POI can do the job. A possible problem depending on the usage your aiming to may be caused by the fact that HWPF is still in early development.

HWPF is the set of APIs for reading and writing Microsoft Word 97(-XP) documents using (only) Java.

smink
I've used this successfully on my production app.
Allain Lalonde
Any knowledge of graph and table possibilities? How about tables of contents? Anyone have real experience doing those things in POI?
Bill James
Looking at the documentation for POI, it seems this HWPF is very early in development, mainly allowing for reading text out of a .doc, not really for dynamic creation of "complex" documents.
Bill James
I don't believe it handles the more complex graphs/tables etc.
Brian Agnew
+2  A: 

You can use a Java COM bridge like JACOB. If it is from client side, another option would be to use Javascript.

Gulzar
Thanks, but it looks like this would require running on a windows machine, no? I clarified the host machine OS after reading this, but thanks for the info.
Bill James
+2  A: 

I've used Aspose.Words to do mail merge in .NET. I believe that they also have a Java version.

tvanfosson
A: 

I have developed pure XML based word files in the past. I used .NET, but the language should not matter since it's truely XML. It was not the easiest thing to do (had a project that required it a couple years ago.) These do only work in Word 2007 or above - but all you need is Microsoft's white paper that describe what each tag does. You can accomplish all you want with the tags the same way as if you were using Word (of course a little more painful initially.)

schmoopy
A: 

After a little more research, I came across iText, a PDF and RTF-file creation API. I think I can use the RTF generation to create a Doc-readable file that can then be edited using Doc and re-saved.

Anyone have any experience with iText, used in this fashion?

Bill James
I have used iText to export to RTF and it's a bit flaky: TOC for example don't work that well and it's really not very easy to use (docs lacking)
AlfaTeK
A: 

Yet another possibility, since this is a web app.

I was able to render an HTML page with the MIME type set to "application/msword", which caused the browser to spawn Word which imported the html just fine, allowing edits and saving just as if I'd output a real Word doc.

Tables work fine, but images I hadn't gotten working yet. It may be as easy as just an tag in the HTML, or I may have to stream a separate part of the response containing the image data in binary, or some other method I haven't come up with yet. :)

Bill James
A: 

I heartily second the suggestion for Apache POI. It creates Word documents directly, with no need for manual tweaking, it supports the most important of Word's formatting, and it's proven Open Source code. There is a bit of API to learn, but it's well worthwhile. Works good, lasts a long time.

iText, on the other hand, is a product you have to pay money for, and PDF is a horrible document format that isn't even the format you wanted in the first place!

I'd abandon your approach of fiddling with MIME settings. Images are only the first of many things that won't work.

But isn't the POI implementation horribly limited? It seems to be able to create/write/read text, but none of the "extras" like tables, images, etc.
Bill James
-1 - POI is limited, iText is free, PDF isn't that bad...
banjollity
+14  A: 

In 2007 my project successfully used OpenOffice.org's Universal Network Objects (UNO) interface to programmatically generate MS-Word compatible documents (*.doc), as well as corresponding PDF documents, from a Java Web application (a Struts/JSP framework).

OpenOffice UNO also lets you build MS-Office-compatible charts, spreadsheets, presentations, etc. We were able to dynamically build sophisticated Word documents, including charts and tables.

We simplified the process by using template MS-Word documents with bookmark inserts into which the software inserted content, however, you can build documents completely from scratch. The goal was to have the software generate report documents that could be shared and further tweaked by end-users before converting them to PDF for final delivery and archival.

You can optionally produce documents in OpenOffice formats if you want users to use OpenOffice instead of MS-Office. In our case the users want to use MS-Office tools.

UNO is included within the OpenOffice suite. We simply linked our Java app to UNO-related libraries within the suite. An OpenOffice Software Developer's Kit (SDK) is available containing example applications and the UNO Developer's Guide.

I have not investigated whether the latest OpenOffice UNO can generate MS-Office 2007 Open XML document formats.

The important things about OpenOffice UNO are:

  1. It is freeware
  2. It supports multiple languages (e.g. Visual Basic, Java, C++, and others).
  3. It is platform-independent (Windows, Linux, Unix, etc.).

Here are some useful web sites:

This is news to me. Thanks for the info!
Bill James
So far, this is the most compatible with the toolset I asked for. I'm going to mark it "accepted". Though I fully recognize that POI is more mainstream, it just doesn't have the functionality I want yet.
Bill James
OOo Java API's are relatively unknown. Unfortunately.
BalusC
A: 

Try Aspose.Words for java.

+1  A: 

There's a tool called JODConverter which hooks into open office to expose it's file format converters, there's versions available as a webapp (sits in tomcat) which you post to and a command line tool. I've been firing html at it and converting to .doc and pdf succesfully it's in a fairly big project, haven't gone live yet but I think I'm going to be using it. http://sourceforge.net/projects/jodconverter/

Andrew Hancox
A: 

docx4j or poi, both of which are ASL v2

@wondersofcomputing: iText is actually free and open source

plutext
A: 

iText is really easy to use.

If you requiere doc files you can call abiword (free lightweigh multi-os text procesor) from the command line, it has several conversion format convert options.

cam2574
A: 

After a little more research, I came across iText, a PDF and RTF-file creation API. I think I can use the RTF generation to create a Doc-readable file that can then be edited using Doc and re-saved.

Anyone have any experience with iText, used in this fashion?

Bill, the POI and iText API are very similar from a programming perspective. I've worked with both in the past and found them both easy to use and well documented.

With iText you gain the advantage of being able to switch between formats (RTF and PDF) with minor change to the code. If I remember correctly the content is laid out using the same calls and then set as PDF or RTF using a few lines of code.

However I believe the formatting in RTF is limited compared to DOC. I don't know if you'll be able to implement the advanced features you are looking for (tables, inline images) without a decent amount of hassle, if at all.

Given what you said that about HWPF not having enough functionality for your needs (I've only dealt with the Excel side of POI) your best bet may be to convince the powers that be that PDF is the best technology for the job.

James McMahon
+2  A: 

Try Aspose.Words for Java, it runs on any OS where Java is installed.

It will output the document to DOC, DOCX or RTF if you need an MS Word output format. All are supported equally well.

Using this API you can create a document from scratch, literally from nodes and set their formatting properties. You can also use a DocumentBuilder which provides higher level methods such as create a table row, insert a field etc. Or you can copy/join/move portions between existing pre created document, say you want to assemble a contract, just grab and copy pieces from several documents and Aspose.Words will merge styles, list formatting etc properly in the resulting document.

You will be able to insert a TOC field using Aspose.Words, but as of today, the TOC field will require a field update when the document is opened in Microsoft Word. However, we are going to release full support for TOC fields early in 2010. E.g. it will build complete TOC as MS Word does it.

I'm on the Aspose.Words team.

romeok
+1  A: 

It was mentioned only briefly once, so I'd like to call out the docx4j library, as I've had more success with docx4j than anything else. Apache POI's support for Word documents isn't very good. Also, unlike Aspose.Words, docx4j is an open source library.

The only drawback is with docx4j you have to create Office Open XML (docx) format documents rather than OLE2-based (doc) format documents. This is the default format for Word 2007, but Word 2003 and earlier users will need to install a compatibility pack.

For my experiences with docx4j (including a tutorial) see this post on my blog.

Joshua Born
A: 

You may use javadocx to generate word documents using only Java. There is a free (LGPL) version. One may also buy a PRO version that is elegible for support.

Eduardo
A: 

Even though this is much later than the request, it might help others. Docmosis provides a Java API for creating documents in doc,pdf,odt format using documents as templates. It uses OpenOffice as the engine to perform the format conversions. Document manipulation and population is performed by Docmosis itself.

jowierun
+2  A: 

You could use this: http://code.google.com/p/java2word

I implemented this API called Java2Word. with a few lines of code, you can generate one Microsoft Word Document.

Eg.:

IDocument myDoc = new Document2004();
myDoc.getBody().addEle(new Heading1("Heading01"));
myDoc.getBody().addEle(new Paragraph("This is a paragraph...")

There is some examples how to use. Basically you will need one jar file. Let me know if you need any further information how to set it up.

*I wrote this because we had one real necessity in a project. More in my blog:

http ://leonardo-pinho.blogspot.com/2010/07/java2word-word-document-generator-from.html *

cheers Leonardo

Leonardo
A: 

try www.pd4ml.com

james