How do properties work in Object Oriented MATLAB?

Question

I am trying to create a MATLAB class with a member variable that's being updated as a result of a method invocation, but when I try to change the property within the class it (apperently, from what I understood from MATLAB's memory management) creates a copy of the object and then modifies it, leaving the original object's property untouched.

classdef testprop  
    properties  
        numRequests=0;  
    end  
    methods  
        function Request(this, val)  
            disp(val);  
            this.numRequests=this.numRequests+1;  
        end  
    end  
end  


a.Request(9);a.Request(5);  
a.numRequests  
ans = 0

Answer 1

Using a Vanilla Class

When using vanilla class you need to tell Matlab to store a modified copy of the object to save the changes in the property value. So,

>> a=testprop
>> a.Request(5); % will NOT change the value of a.numRequests.
5

>> a.Request(5) 
5

>> a.numRequests
ans = 
       0

>> a=a.Request; % However, this will work but as you it makes a copy of variable, a.
5

>> a=a.Request; 
5

>> a.numRequests
ans =
       2

Using the Handle Class

If you inherit from the handle class, that is

classdef testprop < handle

then you can write,

>> a.Request(5);
>> a.Request(5);
>> a.numRequests
ans = 
       2

Update: Using Vanailla Class

As Kamran notes for the above to work the example code in the definition for the method Request in the question's example code needs to be changed to include an output argument of type testprop.

Thanks Kamran.

Answer 2

You have to remember that syntactically in Matlab, you're probably closer to C, than C++ or Java, at least with respect to objects. So, of you want to change the "contents" of a value object (really just a special struct), you need to return the object from the function.

Azim was correct to point out that if you want Singleton behavior (which, from your code, you seem to), you need to use a "handle" class. Instances of classes that derive from Handle all point to a single instance, and operate only on it.

You can read more about the differences between Value and Handle classes.

Answer 3

I made the class testprop and tried to excute the code which Azim suggested but it did not work. When I executed the following command:

a=a.Request(1)

The following error was generated:

??? Error using ==> Request Too many output arguments.

I think the problem is that we did not determine any output when declaring Request method. So we should change it to:

function this = Request(this, val)

and now:

>> a = testprop;
>> a = a.Request(1);        
>> a.numRequests

ans = 1