views:

466

answers:

4

Found UI guidelines of Launcher icon design http://d.android.com/guide/practices/ui_guidelines/icon_design.html but System Icons in recent Android releases doesn't seem to follow these guidelines (icons are flat instead simplified 3D perspective, as described in document).

Are they already obsolete and what are the current guidelines ?

+7  A: 

They don't seem to have updated the guide since the Android 1.5 release, and Android 2.0/2.1 do things very differently for the Launcher icons. I've been effectively ignoring the guide when it comes to icons ever since the Android 2.0 release came out, though most of the other information in the guide seems to apply still (notifications, menu icons, etc.). Since no one enforces the guidelines anyways, it's better to make your app fit with the recent and future versions of Android than to follow the three-major-releases-old outdated guide.

They haven't released any specs or templates for the new flat icons, but the icons for most of the system apps are available in the Android source code to use as reference if you do a checkout (packages/apps/(appname)/res/drawable-hdpi/app_(appname).png, for most of them).

Yoni Samlan
Thanks Yoni, tend to agree with you, but this is "de-facto" solution. I would like some comment form the Android team, that's why I posted it into from-irc tagged group.
Pavel Lahoda
We are looking to update the UI guidelines as soon as possible. What Yoni posted is the best 'workaround' solution at the moment.
Roman Nurik
+1  A: 

Launcher icon guidelines (according to a tweet by Romain Guy) 72x72, flat and no perspective.

Al
A: 

It's worth noting that while the menu and notification icons appear the same, tab icons have also changed. The tab icon style is the same, but the colour scheme is different, using mid-grey icons for inactive tabs, and white icons for foreground tabs.

Kai
+5  A: 

The launcher icon guidelines have just been updated for Eclair:

Roman Nurik
Interesting - it's a complete U turn in some places. Oh well.
Steve H