I'm designing an RESTful API where some calls are public over HTTP, and some require an API key and encryption over HTTPS. I'm deliberating on what response code should be sent if an HTTP request is sent to one of the private resources. So far the only one that jumps out at me is 412 - Precondition Failed, but the standard indicates that the precondition is imposed by the requester not the server.
Is there an appropriate response code for this condition or do I just need to give in and do 400?
The appropriate error code to return would be similar to 403.4 - SSL required.
Although not explicitly documented in the RFC for HTTP 1.1, this behavior does match the requirements outlined there:
The server understood the request, but is refusing to fulfill it. Authorization will not help and the request SHOULD NOT be repeated. If the request method was not HEAD and the server wishes to make public why the request has not been fulfilled, it SHOULD describe the reason for the refusal in the entity. If the server does not wish to make this information available to the client, the status code 404 (Not Found) can be used instead.
Adding your own subcode (as with the SSL example) might be helpful in some cases, but since this subcode would not be meaningful to third parties, I would recommend against it.
So, your final error message would be something like "403 - Private Resource". Note that, even in the case of a missing API key, "401 - Unauthorized" should not be used, unless your API key can actually be transmitted in a WWW-Authenticate header field.
Recommended approach is to drop the connection altogether - i.e. no response at all. Thus you don't need any status code.
Reference - OWASP SSL Best Practices. Search for Http connections should be dropped.
I cannot say if this is broadly accepted by HTTP clients, but speaking strictly RFC, the server should respond with:
HTTP/1.1 426 Upgrade Required
Upgrade: TLS/1.0, HTTP/1.1
Connection: Upgrade