php memory how much is too much

Question

I'm currently re-writing my site using my own framework (it's very simple and does exactly what I need, i've no need for something like Zend or Cake PHP). I've done alot of work in making sure everything is cached properly, caching pages in files so avoid sql queries and generally limiting the number of sql queries.

Overall it looks like it's very speedy. The average time taken for the front page (taken over 100 times) is 0.046152 microseconds.

But one thing i'm not sure about is whether i've done enough to reduce php memory usage. The only time i've ever encountered problems with it is when uploading large files.

Using memory_get_peak_usage(TRUE), which I THINK returns the highest amount of memory used whilst the script has been running, the average (taken over 100 times) is 1572864 bytes.

Is that good?

I realise you don't know what it is i'm doing (it's rather simple, get the 10 latest articles, the comment count for each, get the user controls, popular tags in the sidebar etc). But would you be at all worried with a script using that sort of memory getting hit 50,000 times a day? Or once every second at peak times?

I realise that this is a very open ended question. Hopefully you can understand that it's a bit of a stab in the dark and i'm really just looking for some re-assurance that it's not going to die horribly come re-launch day.

EDIT: Just an mini experiment I did for myself. I downloaded and installed Wordpress and a default installation with no extra add ons, just one user and just one post and it used 10.5 megabytes of memory or "11010048 bytes". Quite pleased with my 1.5mb now.

Answer 1

It is a subjective question. PHP has a lot of overhead and when calling the function with TRUE, that overhead will be included. You'll see what I mean when you call the function in a simple Hello World script. Also keep in mind that results can differ greatly depending on whether PHP is run as an apache module or FastCGI.

Unfortunately, no one can provide assurances. There will always be unforseen variables that can bring down a site. Perform load testing. Use a code profiler to narrow down the location of any bottlenecks to see if there are ways to make those code blocks more efficient

Encyclopaedia Britannica thought they were prepared when they launched their ad-supported encyclopedia ten years ago. The developers didn't know they would be announcing it on Good Morning America the day of the launch. The whole thing came crashing down for days.

Answer 2

Memory usage values can vary heavily and are subject to fluctuation, but as you already say in your update, a regular WordPress instance is much, much fatter than that. I have had great troubles to get the WordPress backend running with a memory_limit of sixteen megabytes - let alone when Plug-ins come into play. So from that, I'd say a peak of 1,5 Megabytes performing normal tasks is quite okay.

Generation time is extremely subject to the hardware your site runs on, obviously. However, a generation time of 0.046152 seconds (I assume you mean seconds here) sounds very okay to me under normal circumstances.

Answer 3

As long as your systems aren't swapping, your memory usage is reasonable. Any additional concern is just premature optimization.