Remove a comma between two specific characters

Question

I currently have the string:

"Blah, blah, blah,~Part One, Part Two~,blah blah"

I need to remove the comma between the ~ character so it reads.

"Blah, blah, blah,~Part One Part Two~,blah blah"

Can anyone help me out please?

Many thanks,

Answer 1

If there is exactly one comma between the ~s and an even number of ~s in all, then

preg_replace("/~([^,]*),([^,]*)~/", "~\1\2~", $text) 

should do it.

Answer 2

$string = "Blah, blah, blah,~Part One, Part Two~,blah blah";
$pos1 = strpos($string, "~");

$substring = substr($string, $strpos, strlen($string));
$pos2 = strpos($string, "~");

$final = substr($substring, $pos1, $pos2);
$replaced = str_replace(",", "", $final);

$newString = str_replace($final, $replaced, $string);
echo $newString;

It does the job, but I wrote it right here and might have problems (at least performance problems).

Answer 3

It may be easier to do this in a few steps:

• Split on ~
• Transform the parts that are "inside" the ~ only
  • Simply replace ',' with ''
• Join the parts back together with ~

---

A regex solution

That said, it is possible to do this in regex, assuming an even number of ~:

<?php

echo preg_replace(
   '/(^[^~]*~)|([^~]*$)|([^,~]*),|([^,~]*~[^~]*~)/',
   '$1$2$3$4',
   'a,b,c,~d,e,f~,g,h,i,~j,k,l,~m,n,o~,q,r,~s,t,u'
);

?>

The above prints (as seen on codepad.org):

a,b,c,~def~,g,h,i,~jkl~m,n,o~qr~s,t,u

How it works

There are 4 cases:

• We're at the beginning of the string, "outside"
  • Just match until we find the first ~, so next time we'll be "inside"
  • So, (^[^~]*~)
• There are no more ~ till the end of the string
  • If there are even number of ~, we'll be "outside"
  • Just match until the end
  • So, ([^~]*$)
• If it's none of the above, we're "inside"
  • Keep finding the next comma before ~ (so we're still "inside")
    • So, ([^,~]*),
  • If we find ~ instead of a comma, then go out, then go back in on the next ~
    • So, ([^,~]*~[^~]*~)

In all case, we make sure we capture enough to reconstruct the string.

References

• regular-expressions.info/Character Classes, Anchors, Grouping and backreferences