Django authentication and Ajax - URLs that require login

Question

I want to add some Ajax-niceness to my Django-coded website.

In my Django code, I use the @login_required decorator from django.contrib.auth.decorators to mark which view requires authentication. The default behavior when a not authenticated user clicks it is to redirect him/her to login page, and then pass the target page.

What I saw on some sites, and really liked, is that when user clicks a link leading to a place restricted to logged-only users, instead of getting redirected to a login page, he/she gets a popup window (via JavaScript) asking him/her to log in or register. There's no redirection part, so no need for a user to use the "back" key if he/she decides he/she really doesn't like the website enough to waste the time registering.

So, the qestion is: how would you manage the task of automatically marking some links as "restricted" so JavaScript can handle their onclick event and display a "please log in" popup?

Answer 1

Sounds like a page template possibility.

1. You could pass a LINK_VIA (or something) that you provide as onClick="return popup(this, 'arg')" or None. Each link would be <A HREF="link" {{LINK_VIA}}>some text</a>.

   • For anonymous sessions, LINK_VIA has a value.
   • For logged in sessions, LINK_VIA is None

2. You could use an {% if %} statement around your <A HREF=...> tags. This seems wordy.

3. You could write your own custom tag with for {% link_via %}. I'm not familiar enough with this, but you can provide the link and text as strings and your tag can generate one of two kinds of links.

Answer 2

I would agree with S.Lott

Make a check in the template, if the user is logged in, just put the link as usual, if not, put something like

<a href="{{link}}" onclick="return login_popup()">

where login_popup would return false if the user says cancel.

This could be probably be done much easier in Jinja2 through its macros.

If the template doesn't know which urls require the user to login, you probably need to re-consider your design.

If you must, I guess you can do the same thing that the django url dispatcher does to discover the view function.
see: django.core.urlresolvers

once you've grabbed the view function you can check if it's decorated with @login_required.

This would be done in a custom tag probably.
If you use Jinja2, you won't need the tag, just implement the function and expose it to the Environment, it's simple but you'll have to do a bit of reading on the API of Jinja2)

Answer 3

I am facing the same issue, and, like you, I would like a simple decorator to wrap around a Django ajax view in order to handle authentication in the same way that I have other views. One approach that seems promising to me is to use such a decorator in conjunction with JavaScript that looks for a certain value in the response.

Here is first draft of the decorator:

def ajax_login_required(view_func):
    def wrap(request, *args, **kwargs):
        if request.user.is_authenticated():
            return view_func(request, *args, **kwargs)
        json = simplejson.dumps({ 'not_authenticated': True })
        return HttpResponse(json, mimetype='application/json')
    wrap.__doc__ = view_func.__doc__
    wrap.__dict__ = view_func.__dict__
    return wrap

Here is the view:

@ajax_login_required
def ajax_update_module(request, module_slug, action):
    # Etc ...
    return HttpResponse(json, mimetype='application/json')

And here is the JavaScript (jQuery):

$.post('/restricted-url/', data, function(json) {
    if (json.not_authenticated) {
        alert('Not authorized.');  // Or something in a message DIV
        return;
    }
    // Etc ...
});