I've tried in MSIE4 - 8... not working in any of them (MSIE4-6 returns blank page, 7 and 8 returns the mentioned error)
I've also checked with Firebug and it seems that:
- a request to the following address, which returns error 400 is made on the page: http://www.kanyetothe.com/forum/%smileySource% - this probably won't solve the problem, as it's on multiple pages and the others work, just a thing worth fixing
- gzip compression is enabled on the server - probably works fine, just a thing to have in mind when debugging
Furthermore, there are errors in the actual code - you have 2 closing tags for BODY and HTML at the end, and some HEAD data which are inserted after the HEAD section is actually being closed.
Can't say whether any of this will help you solve the mentioned problem but at least you have something to start with :)