Good comparison Doctrine vs Propel

Question

Hi!

I've seen plenty of comparisons of Doctrine vs Propel, but none of them has actually convinced me to choose Doctrine over Propel.

I've been using Propel for a while now and almost every comparison I read states that Propel is not well documented as the first problem and I've read Propel's docs and they're quite well. Also, most of comparisons are dated, (using Propel > 1.5 )

My question is : Does anyone knows of a highly convincing post in a blog where I can see test results and some actual differences?

Hope someone can help me!

[Edit]

Small Typo, Im asking comparison using Propel 1.5 or higher (1.6 is still in beta, but we dont know when the next reply can be :) )

Answer 1

I was using Propel for 1,5 years too(with Symfony 1.0). But then I got a project with Doctrine ORM. I wasn't very happy about it(because I didn't know Doctrine at all), but after few days of working with Doctrine I forgot about Propel.)) As for Propel, it took me about few weeks to be able to use it.

Here are to links from Google(they are at the top of search results):

• http://codeutopia.net/blog/2008/03/02/doctrine-vs-propel/

• http://codeutopia.net/blog/2009/05/16/doctrine-vs-propel-2009-update/.

As for me, it was enough to see advantages of Doctrine. You should simply try Doctrine(it'd be better to see real project with this ORM) and then you will understand it by yourself.

To my mind, Doctrine is much much more convenient and faster then Propel in development. And also Doctrine looks like native SQL, so it's easier to understand and debug code.

Answer 2

I suspect you were around when I asked my question yesterday on freenode?

Most of the time, it's not technical differences that drive people away, but the community. If it doesn't have a vibrant and active community to back it up and answer questions, no matter how much better it is, people will be driven away.