Hibernate Criteria API - HAVING clause work arounds

Question

I've written a query using Hibernate Criteria API to grab a summation of a particular value, now I need to be able to restrict the result to rows where that sum is greater or equal to a particular value.

Normally I would use a HAVING clause in my SQL to do this, but the Criteria API doesn't seem to support that at this moment.

In raw SQL this is what I need it to do:

SELECT user_pk, sum(amount) as amountSum
FROM transaction
GROUP BY user_pk
HAVING amountSum >=50;

One work-around that I thought of is to use a subquery in the FROM clause that grabs this summation value and use an outer query to restrict it using a WHERE clause.

So, in raw SQL it will look something like:

SELECT user_pk, amountSum
FROM (SELECT user_pk, sum(amount) as amountSum
      FROM transaction
      GROUP BY user_pk)
WHERE amountSum > 50;

Can anyone point me in the right direction as to how I could write this using Criteria API, or any other suggestions/work-arounds I can use to solve the HAVING issue?

This is the Criteria API code I have for the above example

DetachedCriteria criteria = DetachedCriteria.forClass(Transaction.class,"transaction");
criteria.setProjection(criteria.setProjection(Projections.projectionList().add(
  Projections.groupProperty("user.userPK").as("user_pk")).add(
         Projections.sum("transaction.amount").as("amountSum")));

Thanks!

Answer 1

I don't know of a way for Hibernate/NHibernate to use a subquery in the FROM clause but you can use them in the WHERE clause. Apologies for any Java/Hibernate code mistakes, I am more familiar with C#/NHibernate.

DetachedCriteria subQuery = DetachedCriteria.forClass(Transaction.class);
subQuery.setProjection(Projections.sum("amount"));
subQuery.add(Expression.eqProperty("userPk", "tOuter.userPk"));

DetachedCriteria outerQuery = DetachedCriteria.forClass(Transaction.class, "tOuter");
outerQuery.setProjection(Projections.projectionList()
    .Add(Projections.sum("amount").as("sumAmount"))
    .Add(Projections.groupProperty("userPk").as("user_pk"));
outerQuery.add(Subqueries.le(50, subQuery));

This code should result in SQL similar to:

SELECT tOuter.userPk as user_pk, sum(tOuter.amount) as sumAmount
FROM transaction tOuter
WHERE 50 <= (SELECT sum(amount) FROM transaction WHERE userPk = tOuter.userPk)
GROUP BY tOuter.userPk

The disadvantage of this approach is that it calculates each of the sums twice, this might have a detrimental effect on performance depending on the amount of data involved - in which case you will want to use an HQL query which does support the HAVING clause.

Answer 2

http://opensource.atlassian.com/projects/hibernate/browse/HHH-1700

Answer 3

HHH-1700 was marked as a duplicate of HHH-1043, and therefore won't be fixed. You'll find my solution and workaround, as well as other peoples', on HHH-1043.