It's extremely subjective and argumentative questions. I probably should close it :)
There is no common definition of "beautiful software" or "Software Masterpiece"
Some people would appreciate robustness of code, others will be pleased with obscure tricky solutions.
For example, some of the code in the book mentioned by @Jason Baker is totally human hostile :) But someone decided that it is beautiful.
This discussion could be much more useful if you define what "Software Masterpiece" means to you.
Are you looking for extremely useful solution or obscure tricky code?
My current favorite is Launchy - nothing need to be added\removed, ideal! :)