views:

1049

answers:

4

Hi all,

This is my first Q here :)

I recently have taken the support and programming of a web system written in JSF. The code is kind of messy and redundant, and yes, no documentation exists.

The system has over 40 jar libraries, and most of them are redundant due to old versions and testing. To remove one jar, I must check that it's not imported in the code, so I searched the code for the jar import path (I'm using IntelliJ IDE), made sure that it's not used, and removed it.

However, after compiling the code, a number of run-time errors occurred during testing. I figured out that I removed some jars which are used by other existing jars.

The problem, how do I make sure before removing a jar that it's not used by another jar/java class?

Despite that jars have compiled classes, the compiled classes do have the import path of required libraries. But I can't search them with IntelliJ (does not search inside jars files).

The only way that I'm doing now is to test the system every time I remove a jar and see if I can crash it! This is totally not an easy way due to the huge number of features to be tested.

I wish that there is a tool where I can submit a number of java files/jars, and it displays the dependencies between them.

This brings me to an issue that the idea jars is not that feasible. I may write about this in another question.

Thanks

+1  A: 

why don't you use Maven for your project? that will help you a lot managing dependencies.

silmx
The Maven site plugin will generate reports including dependencies.
Chris Nava
The Maven plugin in NetBeans 6.7 includes a graphical dependency viewer for the Jars: http://wiki.netbeans.org/NewAndNoteworthyMilestone3NB67
mjustin
+4  A: 

I know that there was a tool coming out of the JBoss project called JBoss TattleTale, might be worth taking a look:

http://www.jboss.org/tattletale

Uri
+1 this tool is still very new but gives some good info. It even shows you dependencies between classes in the jar files. Too bad it doesn't work with maven though.
Peter D
Exactly what I need! I tested it and it provided me with cool reports about the jar dependencies and more. Thanks!
Saleh Al-Zaid
Glad I could help. I think it uses GraphViz to visualize the graphs, there are ways to tweak it a little to look even better.
Uri
+2  A: 

JDepend will analyze dependencies for you for any number of JARs, class files, etc. Related the packages it reports to those JARs should be a trivial extra step.

Nick Veys
+1 vote for JDepend
mjustin
I tested JDepend too, but it's too far complicated in viewing dependencies than jboss tattletale. But has an advantage, it shows the dependencies between classes too and not just the jars.Thanks
Saleh Al-Zaid
A: 
JRL