How to deserialize an object persited in a db now when the obect has different serialVersionUID

Question

My client has an oracle data base and an object was persisted as a blob field via objOutStream.writeObject, the object now has a different serialVersionUID (even though the object has no change, maybe different jvm version) and when they try to de-serialize an exception is thrown:

java.io.InvalidClassException: CommissionResult; local class incompatible: 
 stream classdesc serialVersionUID = 8452040881660460728, 
 local class serialVersionUID = -5239021592691549158

They didn't assign a fixed value for serialVersionUID since the beginning so now that some thing changed that exception is thrown. Now they don't want to loose any data, to do so I think the best is to read the objects, de-serialize them, and persist them again via XMLEncoder to avoid future errors like the current "class incompatible" error.

Apparently there are 2 different values for the serialVersionUID persisted for that object so I want to read the data, try with one value and if it fails then try with the other value, To do so I've tried to change the serialVersionUID of the class using the ASM api. I've been able to change the value but the problem is how to make active the change upon the class so when it is de-serialized the objInpStr.readObject() take my modified version of the class with my specific serializedVersionUID. I made a test class to simulate the real environment, I take an object (which has as property the object with different serialVersionUID problem) the object name is Reservation the property is CommissionResult:

public class Reservation implements java.io.Serializable {


    private CommissionResult commissionResult = null;

}


public class CommissionResult implements java.io.Serializable{



}


import org.objectweb.asm.ClassReader;
import org.objectweb.asm.ClassVisitor;
import org.objectweb.asm.ClassWriter;
import org.objectweb.asm.commons.SerialVersionUIDAdder;

public class SerialVersionUIDRedefiner extends ClassLoader {


    public void workWithFiles() {
     try {
      Reservation res = new Reservation();
      FileOutputStream f = new FileOutputStream("/home/xabstract/tempo/res.ser");
     ObjectOutputStream out = new ObjectOutputStream(f);

      out.writeObject(res);

      out.flush();
      out.close();

      ClassWriter cw = new ClassWriter(0); 
       ClassVisitor sv = new SerialVersionUIDAdder(cw); //assigns a real serialVersionUID 
       ClassVisitor ca = new MyOwnClassAdapter(sv); //asigns my specific serialVerionUID value
       ClassReader cr=new  ClassReader("Reservation"); 
        cr.accept(ca, 0); 

       SerialVersionUIDRedefiner  loader= new SerialVersionUIDRedefiner(); 
       byte[] code = cw.toByteArray();
       Class exampleClass =   loader.defineClass("Reservation", code, 0, code.length); //at this point the class Reservation has an especific serialVersionUID value that I put with MyOwnClassAdapter

       loader.resolveClass(exampleClass);
       loader.loadClass("Reservation");
       DeserializerThread dt=new DeserializerThread();
       dt.setContextClassLoader(loader);
       dt.run();
    } catch (Exception e) {
      e.printStackTrace();
    }}



import java.io.FileInputStream;
import java.io.ObjectInputStream;

public class DeserializerThread extends Thread {

    public void run() {
     try {
      FileInputStream f2;

      f2 = new FileInputStream("/home/xabstract/tempo/res.ser");

       ObjectInputStream in = new ObjectInputStream(f2);


      Reservation c1 = (Reservation)in.readObject();



      System.out.println(c1);

     } catch (Exception e) {

      e.printStackTrace();
     }
     stop();
    }
}

MyOwnClassAdapter Relevant code:



public void visitEnd() {
        // asign SVUID and add it to the class

            try {

                cv.visitField(Opcodes.ACC_FINAL + Opcodes.ACC_STATIC,
                        "serialVersionUID",
                        "J",
                        null,
                        new Long(-11001));//computeSVUID()));
            } catch (Throwable e) {
                e.printStackTrace();
                throw new RuntimeException("Error while computing SVUID for x"
                        , e);
            }


        super.visitEnd();
    }

The test should fail with the java.io.InvalidClassException "local class incompatible" because I changed the serialVersionUID after I saved the file and used a new one to read de file but it doesn't fails so it means that the ObjectInputStream.readObject is not using my modified version of the Reservation class.

Any Ideas? Thanks in advance.

!!!!!!!!!!!!!UPDATE:

Ok, it is possible to redefine the resultClassDescriptor to override the stream serialVersionUID, but, some thing strange happens, as I said before it seems there are 2 versions of the class persisted, objects with serialVersionUID = -5239021592691549158L and others with value 8452040881660460728L this last value is the one generated if I don't specify a value to the local class.

-If I don't specify a value for the serialVersionUID then the default value (8452040881660460728L) is used, but is not possible to de-serealize the objects that has the other value, an error is thrown saying that a property is of an other type.

-If I specify the value -5239021592691549158L then classes persisted with that value are successfully de-serialized, but not the others, same error of types.

this is the error trace :

Potentially Fatal Deserialization Operation. java.io.InvalidClassException: Overriding serialized class version mismatch: local serialVersionUID = -5239021592691549158 stream serialVersionUID = 8452040881660460728 java.lang.ClassCastException: cannot assign instance of java.util.HashMap to field com.posadas.ic.rules.common.commisionRules.CommissionResult.statusCode of type java.lang.String in instance of com.posadas.ic.rules.common.commisionRules.CommissionResult

When this error was thrown the class had the value of -5239021592691549158, if change the value to 8452040881660460728 the class is successfully de-serialized, so, what happens? why is that error that tries to cast for wrong class ?

Thanks

Answer 1

I may be missing something, but it sounds like you're trying to do something more complicated than necessary. What happens if:

(a) you take the current class definition (i.e. the source code) and hard-code its serial UID to the old one (or one of the old ones), then use that class definition to deserialise the serialised instances?

(b) in the byte stream you're reading, you replace the old serial UIDs with the new one before wrapping the ObjectInputStream around them?

OK, just to clarify (b). So for example, if I have a little class like this:

  public static class MyClass implements Serializable {
    static final long serialVersionUID = 0x1122334455667788L;
    private int myField = 0xff;
  }

then when the data is serialised, it looks something like this:

ACED000573720011746573742E546573 ’..sr..test.Tes
74244D79436C61737311223344556677 t$MyClass."3DUfw
880200014900076D794669656C647870 ?...I..myFieldxp
000000FF ...ÿ

Each line is 16 bytes, and each byte is 2 hex digits. If you look carefully, on the second line, 9 bytes (18 digits) in, you'll see the serial version ID starts (1122...). So in our data here (yours will differ slightly), the offset of the serial version ID is 16 + 9 = 25 (or 0x19 in hex). So before I start deserialising, if I want to change this serial version ID to something else, then I need to write my new number at offset 25:

byte[] bytes = ... serialised data ...
ByteBuffer bb = ByteBuffer.wrap(bytes);
bb.putLong(25, newSerialVersionUID);

then I just proceed as normal:

ObjectInputStream oin = new ObjectInputStream(new ByteArrayInputStream(bytes));
MyClass obj = (MyClass) oin.readObject();

Answer 2

If you've got multiple versions of the class stored in the database, it might be pretty tricky to deserialize and upgrade them all to a consistent serialization format in a single pass.

If possible, you might alter the table with a column to flag whether the serialized object has been processed yet. Then make passes over the table for each serialVersionUID, where you try to process any objects that haven't been dealt with yet. You can catch the InvalidClassException and go on to the next record if your updater encounters a serialized object that it doesn't handle, making a note of the version number so that you can make another pass.

This is a little tedious, but very simple.

Java serialization has some very nice features to support evolution of classes. However, you have to be aware of what you are doing. It may be that all of the objects actually have the same data, but no attention was paid to maintaining the version ID.

You could continue to use serialization once you get all of the objects updated to the same version. Just be careful as you add new fields to the class that they make sense with their default values (booleans are false, Objects are null, ints are zero, etc).

Answer 3

You should be able to hack around the issue by overriding ObjectInputStream.readClassDescriptor.

Using XMLEncoder wont actually help with version migration as the compatibility rules are much the same. Really what should probably be doing is persisting the object in a relational form with the help of an ORM tool.

Probably the different serialVersionUIDs happened due to different synthetic members being generated by javac. Head the warnings and put serialVersionUID in.

Answer 4

Jorge I found one solution on http://forums.sun.com/thread.jspa?threadID=518416 which works.

Create the below class in your project. Whereever you creating object of ObjectInputStream, use DecompressibleInputStream instead and it deserializes the old object with the new version Id class.

public class DecompressibleInputStream extends ObjectInputStream {

    public DecompressibleInputStream(InputStream in) throws IOException {
        super(in);
    }


    protected ObjectStreamClass readClassDescriptor() throws IOException, ClassNotFoundException {
        ObjectStreamClass resultClassDescriptor = super.readClassDescriptor(); // initially streams descriptor
        Class localClass = Class.forName(resultClassDescriptor.getName()); // the class in the local JVM that this descriptor represents.
        if (localClass == null) {
            System.out.println("No local class for " + resultClassDescriptor.getName());
            return resultClassDescriptor;
        }
        ObjectStreamClass localClassDescriptor = ObjectStreamClass.lookup(localClass);
        if (localClassDescriptor != null) { // only if class implements serializable
            final long localSUID = localClassDescriptor.getSerialVersionUID();
            final long streamSUID = resultClassDescriptor.getSerialVersionUID();
            if (streamSUID != localSUID) { // check for serialVersionUID mismatch.
                final StringBuffer s = new StringBuffer("Overriding serialized class version mismatch: ");
                s.append("local serialVersionUID = ").append(localSUID);
                s.append(" stream serialVersionUID = ").append(streamSUID);
                Exception e = new InvalidClassException(s.toString());
                System.out.println("Potentially Fatal Deserialization Operation. " + e);
                resultClassDescriptor = localClassDescriptor; // Use local class descriptor for deserialization
            }
        }
        return resultClassDescriptor;
    }
}