JAXB Marshalling and Generics

Question

I am trying to use JAXB's introspection to marshall and unmashall some existing domain objects marked up with JAXB annotations. Most things work as expected, but I am having quite a bit of trouble getting a fairly simple class to serialize. This class is used as an @XmlElement on a number of beans and looks something like:

public class Range<E extends Comparable<E>> implements Serializable {
    protected boolean startInclusive, endInclusive;
    protected E       start, end;

    public Range(){
            startInclusive = endInclusive = true;
    }

    public boolean contains(E value){...}

    public E getEnd() {
            return end;
    }

    public void setEnd(E end) {
            this.end = end;
    }

    public boolean isEndInclusive() {
            return endInclusive;
    }

    public void setEndInclusive(boolean endInclusive) {
            this.endInclusive = endInclusive;
    }

    public E getStart() {
            return start;
    }

    public void setStart(E start) {
            this.start = start;
    }

    public boolean isStartInclusive() {
            return startInclusive;
    }

    public void setStartInclusive(boolean startInclusive) {
            this.startInclusive = startInclusive;
    }
}

I have tried to do the following, with no success, JAXB is still angry with the interface Comparable.

public class DoubleRange extends Range<Double> {}

Using both Range and DoubleRange as return types for the bean getter's yields an exception like:

java.lang.Comparable is an interface, and JAXB can't handle interfaces.
    this problem is related to the following location:
     at java.lang.Comparable
     at protected java.lang.Comparable com.controlpath.util.Range.start
     at example.util.Range
     at example.util.DoubleRange
     at public example.util.DoubleRange example.domain.SomeBean.getRange()
     at example.domain.SomeBean

I realize that in most cases List<T> and Map<T, U> only work because the JAXB specification has special provisions for those types when they are encountered on beans, but is there any way to convey what I want to the JAXB introspection engine without having to reimplement range with non-generic fields?

Answer 1

Try something like Simple XML Serialization it comes with support for generic types in XML elements with a number of annotations such as @Element and @ElementList. The programming model is very similar, but simpler than JAXB.

Answer 2

So it looks like the problem is the erasure of E on start and end is Comparable. If it can't handle interfaces you could try Object, but I would hope it complains at that too (either now or later). Possibly you could make Range abstract and specialise it for each specific E. I should know more about JAXB.

Answer 3

You could write a custom adapter (not using JAXB's XmlAdapter) by doing the following:

1) declare a class which accepts all kinds of elements and has JAXB annotations and handles them as you wish (in my example I convert everything to String)

@YourJAXBAnnotationsGoHere
public class MyAdapter{

  @XmlElement // or @XmlAttribute if you wish
  private String content;

  public MyAdapter(Object input){
    if(input instanceof String){
      content = (String)input;
    }else if(input instanceof YourFavoriteClass){
      content = ((YourFavoriteClass)input).convertSomehowToString();
    }else if(input instanceof .....){
      content = ((.....)input).convertSomehowToString();
    // and so on
    }else{
      content = input.toString();
    }
  }
}

// I would suggest to use a Map<Class<?>,IMyObjToStringConverter> ...
// to avoid nasty if-else-instanceof things

2) use this class instead of E in your to-be-marshalled class

NOTES

• Of course this would not work for complex (nested) data structures.
• You have to think how to unmarshall this back again, could be more tricky. If it's too tricky, wait for a better proposal than mine ;)

Answer 4

And, how about

public class Range<E extends Number> implements Serializable { ...

• Number is a class

• I bet JAXB knows default marshalling/unmarshalling rules for Number

For unmarshalling to specific type, you need XmlAdapter as I described here

Answer 5

Actually, it is not quite clear to me why this would not work. It seems like JAXB should be able to resolve specific subtype correctly: if (and only if!) this type is NOT the root type (which it is not as per your description). I mean, it is just a Bean; so if bean with T replaced with direct type works, so should generic version iff using sub-classing to bind types (as is done in example).

So perhaps it could be a bug in implementation?