Where is allocated variable reference, in stack or in the heap ?

Question

Hi all members of stackoverflow, I have a question

What happend when I declare a variable inside a method, for example.

void myMethod() {
    Ship myShip = new Ship();
}

Where is allocated myShip reference, in stack or in the heap ?

I think in stack but I'm confused because I was reading in J2ME Game Programming book "Java classes are instantiated onto the Java heap"

All java clases ?

Thanks in advance

Answer 1

Java really does things a bit differently. The reference is basically on the stack. The memory for the object is allocated in what passes for the heap. However, the implementation of allocable memory isn't quite like the way the heap is implemented in the C/C++ model.

When you create a new object like that, it effectively puts the name into the table of references for that scope. That's much like a pointer to an object in C++. When it goes out of scope, that reference is lost; the allocated memory is no longer referenced, and can be garbage-collected.

Answer 2

Currently, all Java objects are allocated on the heap. There is talk that Java 7 might do escape analysis and be able to allocate on the stack, but I don't know if the proposal is finalized yet. Here's the RFE.

Edit: Apparently, it's already in early builds of JDK 7. (The article says it will also be in JDK 6u14, but I can't find confirmation.)

Answer 3

Notionally, the object goes on "the heap". Then, because it's a method-local reference, the actual reference will be on the stack. By "the" stack, we mean the native thread stack (i.e. the same stack that a local variable in C would be allocated on) in the case of Sun's VM at least, but I don't think that's actually a requirement (the JVM just has to have some abstract notion of "stack frames" that it allocates on each method call, be it from the native stack or not).

But... on modern VMs (with admittedly the possible exception of simpler embedded/mpbile VMs), there's really no such thing as "the" heap. In practice, there are various heap areas. The simplest of these is typically almost like a "mini stack", designed to be quick to allocate for objects that won't hang around for long and can probably be de-allocated almost at once.

As mentioned by another poster, a highly optimised JVM could in principle allocate object data on the stack and there are definite proposals for this. Although, as also mentioned in one of the references, a criticism of this is that the fast "eden" heap is almost like a stack anyway (just not "the" stack).

Answer 4

myShip is a reference to a Ship object, it is on the method call stack, which is referred to as "the stack". When a method is called a block of memory is pushed onto the top the stack, that memory block has space for all primitives (int, float, boolean etc) and object references of the method. The heap is where the memory for the actual objects is allocated.

So myShip is on the stack and the Ship object is on the heap.

Note each thread has its own stack but share the heap.