views:

2851

answers:

4

I am looking for a good role based authorization solution to use alongside Authlogic. Anyone have any good suggestions? Please list some pros and cons from your experience if possible please.

+4  A: 

At RailsConf, I saw a lightning talk on Lockdown and was very impressed. Anyone with a modest amount of db and rails experience can roll their own ACL system, but Lockdown looks nice because it tries to keep the permission stuff out of the way.

http://lockdown.rubyforge.org/

I had used role_requirement previously but I didn't dig it.

Brian Hogan
Lockdown looks good.
JasonOng
+3  A: 

Acl9 works great with AuthLogic:

http://github.com/be9/acl9/tree/master

Jaryl
really like it. but it should totally be called yarba (yet another role based authorization - from the description).
taelor
totally =) oh yeah, about pros and cons, it's really simple to get going (the documentation makes it seem more difficult than it is). On thing that could be useful is a method to collect all the subjects for a given role. I requested for that feature but I don't know if the author put it in.
Jaryl
more recent gem to do this:http://github.com/stffn/declarative_authorization
Jaryl
+1  A: 

Check out http://blog.platform45.com/2009/10/05/howto-basic-roles-for-users for basic role requirement, works with restful_authentication and authlogic..

It's really simple, fast and lightweight.

Ryan
link no longer works
Nathan Hurst
+1  A: 

I have recently have been using a gem called easy_roles. Super light weight and super easy to use. It's also flexible enough for you to implement your own controller security etc etc.

http://github.com/platform45/easy_roles

Ryan