Is the [Authorize] attribute for ASP.NET MVC controllers only for Membership Providers?

Question

Does the [Authorize] attribute used with ASP.NET MVC controllers only function with sites that have implemented a MembershipProvider?

Answer 1

I'm pretty sure it does yes. I imagine you could role your own and implement a similar way of doing authentication/authorization.

Answer 2

The [Authorize] attribute is an action filter. It's going to grab the IPrincipal and check if the user is authenticated or if you specify roles and/or users in with the attribute, it will match against those.

There are many ways that a web request can be authenticated. Everything from Open ID to Windows Authentication. Check out this question for an OpenID example and more links to implementing authentication that way: StackOverflow Question 961468

Answer 3

Short answer is no. It just checks that there is a IPrincipal, how that gets there is up to you.

I have my own login logic that I use instead of the Membership provider, once I've authenticated a user I just call the FormsAuthentication.SetAuthCookie method. Once you've done that you can then use the [Authenticate] attribute.